Reviews for Nicky's Coal Fired in Nashville, TN
Been wanting to come here for a while and finally have. Cheese sticks were good and marinara tasted unique, like it was... homemade. Pizza was good but not great. One thing that disappointed me was my pizza was not. I feel like it sat out too longbefore it was brought to me. I ended up eating a few slices and and just taking the rest home where I can reheat it. Curious totry other things on the menu as they have more then just pizza. They dipping sauces garlic and the ranch were delicious! Read more
It was barely OK. Was expecting so much more from all reviews. Focaccia bread was burnt. I don't mean over cooked, it was... burnt! The server laughed when she placed it on the table. When she brought the pizza we never saw her again. Had to go findsomeone to get us a box. Won't be back. Read more
Food was good but some how my order got "bumped" and had to wait over 45 minutes for on pizza. I'll have to give them another... try. They did apologize and refunded my order and brought a tiramisu. Read more
It was fine, but I have no desire to return. If you're in the area, I'd say a visit is worth it once. We drove from... Hendersonville to check it out with some friends and felt it definitely wasn't worth the drive. If I did ever find myself backover there, the only thing worth ordering again would be the gnocchi. Other than that, it was mostly mediocre. Staff was greathowever. Read more
...5 ???? ? !! I've waited forever to get to Nicky's. Been following them on IG a while longing for the dishes they post... especially the "coal fired pizza" and needless to say they did NOT disappoint... Celebrated the last day of 2021 with some clinkclink drinks, the freshest of salads, fire roasted Olives, ummm yumm ???? and the long awaited coal fired pizza- "Hey Paisano" (cappicola on the side please) drizzled w/ spicy honey ( oh Hello) OK ABSOLUTELY Ridiculously DELICIOUS!! Sitting under theChristmas lights and Tinsel garland I couldn't help but get a little misty eyed amidst the homemade Italian aromas and ambiancethat took me back to South Philly- Simple pleasures are our greatest treasures and Nicky's in Nashville is just that! TheStaff, The Chef & His Crew my goodness such awesome people making & serving scrumptious food with passion and love for theirguests. IF you haven't, YOU must.. if you DON'T you are MISSING out on some of the most insanely freshly made fabulous Italianfood one can indulge in ~ in Nashville, TN ????????????????????THANK YOU Nicky's for the BEST NYE Dinner my Hound Brown & Ishared with all of you #NashvilleLove ???????????? Read more
The pizzas are truly artisan; amazing crust and inventive creations. I also enjoyed the spaghetti and gulf shrimp plate.... Although there was plenty of seasoning (and garlic) the funk of the shrimp was still over-powering Very cool atmosphere. AndMarshall was amazing in his service Read more
We got the gnocchi with beef, squash ravioli, and spinach-artichoke pizza. All of it was absolutely amazing. We couldn’t eat... it fast enough. Wanted to order seconds of everything but all three of us were full. Service was ?????????? basically had 3people waiting on us. Can’t wait to come back and bring more friends to enjoy it. Read more
Man, can say enough good things about the pizza! Coming from Kansas we love trying new places in different cities! This is a... must stop! I'll be back next time in March! Read more