Reviews for Casey's in Nauvoo, IL
I didn?t have the pizza, but I went in to buy a bottle of Diet Coke. No bottles of Diet Coke. In fact, the store kinda looked... like a zombie apocalypse had hit. This was the middle of the day on a Monday. Read more
Two words: tasty pizza. There's not much to eat in the area, and this Casey's delivers some quality pizza. I make it a point to... stop here when visiting. Read more
Our family loves making our traditional annual autumn trip to Nauvoo. We?ve been enjoying Sunday brunch in autumn at Hotel... Nauvoo for 65 years now! After the perfect meal at Hotel Nauvoo we toured the homes in this historic, beautiful town, & thendrove along the river, & back, before the 75 mile return drive home. We stopped at this local Casey?s to purchase gas, treats,& bottled water, before the long drive home. We asked the young blonde woman behind the counter if we could use the restroomfacilities before heading home. The young lady told us we weren?t allowed to use their public restroom, & told us to go downthe street to ?Dollar General? and ?maybe? Dollar General would allow us to use their restroom. This remark, after we paid goodmoney to buy gas and products at Casey?s. We would have returned to Hotel Nauvoo, but being a Sunday, the Hotel closed at 2 PM. We asked this young lady ? what do staff do if they have to use the restroom facilities? The young lady told us staff areallowed to use the restroom there. I told her because we were paying customers we too should be allowed to use the restroom. Shethen told us their public toilet didn?t work, & leaks water all over the floor, adding they won?t allow customers use of theirpublic restroom for fear we customers will slip on the water, and injure ourselves. This young lady did not greet us when weentered Casey?s, there were no other customers in the building, but one other staff woman behind the food prep area. This younglady looked at us and said ?is this all you want?? We paid the young lady for our gas, treats, & bottled water, and thanked her,however this young lady said absolutely nothing. No ?thank you?. She was rude and it was obvious she was bored standing therebehind the counter. Never have we received such a reception in the beautiful town of Nauvoo. Truly, everyone we have always metin this wonderful sacred place has been loving, and even though we are strangers we have always Read more
Matt Van Horn makes THE best pizza...get your pizza when he's there. Not sure what he does, but his is different. The locals... tell me they go to Casey's to get their pizza when Matt is there because he not only will make a stellar pizza, generous withtoppings, but maybe, just maybe do a spot-on voice impression of the Joker. He also knows the locals by name, and knows theirfavorite pizzas. The employees are really cool, and the manager Tina runs a tight ship with a pleasant attitude. The employeesare well-trained to make a mean pizza. Excellent quality. Read more
Friendly staff, great pizza, but wish they had better selection of hot food. The donuts are good. Would love to see long... john's and turnovers with no filling. Read more
Even though Masons pizza is good, Mathews pizza is too good to be True. Legend has it he's had people tell him that he could win... contests with his pizza. And that he only comes out to make pizza when there's a full moon and the clock has struck 4. His pizzais of rare quality that is only matched by few in the entire country. Read more
I went in and ordered a pizza, the employees were very funny, tall, and goodlooking. Btw best pizza I've ever had, request Mason... to make them. He pours his soul into every pizza. It is truly magical and one of a kind. Overall amazing experience. Read more
A respectable establishment whose 'Star rating' does not do justice for. $2.99 for a single filling slice.