Reviews for Agave & Rye in New Albany, IN
My fiance and I came here for his birthday dinner and sat in the outdoor rooftop dining and bar area. Our server was Alek. He... was so so so sweet, informative of all products and availability on ingredients, as well as just a general good person. Eventhough we went for his birthday, I was asked not to say anything to anyone about it but I was given 2 opportunities to see howthey celebrate birthdays for two other tables. They give a card signed by the restaurant staff! A dessert with a lit sparkler,too! A lot of care and love go into everything they do. All the food was delicious! I had The Swipe Right taco and we sharedguacamole appetizer and my fiance got The Yoda taco. If you ever have the chance to stop here for a drink and a small bite orjust a drink or two. Do it! The really intricate interior and exterior design and decorating is beautiful and well cared for!Flowers and plants all over for the season, even on the steps going to the rooftop. Unique art installments. It's a full win inall areas! Our server Alek was great as mentioned, and every employee we encountered were friendly and smiled with a genuinesmile, not a 'fake welcome's type. So walking in was a good experience from the first step in to the first step out! Read more
Pretty good food, but the atmosphere is the best part. Update: went back another time. Tried 3 different tacos and they were... also just okay. I don't think I will be returning as there are better taco places around that are also less expensive. Read more
We had one of the best dining experiences at Agave and Rye. We were in town for a wedding and I am so glad this was within... walking distance of our airbnb. Paige was so helpful and gave us the absolute best recommendations. The food and margaritas werejust phenomenal. Highly recommend the Epic Margarita and the sticky cauliflower bites! Read more
I loved the setting. The wooden horse was pretty cool. Amy was my server and was very friendly. She walked me through the menu... and pointed vegan options out to me. I had the faux Gen tso taco. It was tasty! The fries were perfectly cooked and hot whenthey came out. I like the idea of the red and green card to indicate if your just chillin (red) and don't need anything or thegreen side if you do. I ate in the patio and a couple young women brought their leashed dog so that's cool to know if I have mydog next time. Read more
Oh giva me some more Agave and Rye!!! Our walking group went her for lunch and oh my!! The best taco I have ever had and yes I... have had many tacos! I had the plain Jane and it was a perfect epic regular taco! They have many kinds of tacos and next time Imay venture out to one of the unusual ones. Also got their chips and queso.. and the queso was so cheesy and Not spicy.. exactlyas I like it! Our server did a great job with a big group. They were busy and seemed to have lots of servers.. it felt likeeating out BC (before Covid) Thank you Agave.. I will be back with more friends. Read more
Literally the BEST taco I've ever eaten other than my wife's. I'll be back. Place was clean, staff was nice, sat at the bar but... didn't drink(left a good size tip). Read more
It says Epic Tacos on the building and it was so true. The food was absolutely fantastic and came in generous portions. The... service was even better. They had the best Brussels sprouts I've ever had. I had a taco with tater tots, salsa, queso, a friedegg and a few candied jalapenos on top. Whoever put that one together is a genius. The decor is funky and gorgeous. The staffwas attentive, friendly, good at their jobs and actually seemed happy to be there. You will not be disappointed if you visitthis great restaurant. Read more
The food is amazing!! I love tacos and trying unique food combinations. Agave & Rye allows you to do both! I had 2 tacos on my... last visit, both of which I would totally order again. My mother ordered the birria ramen. The only things people might find alittle off-putting are the unconventional art and slightly loud music. I don't really mind though! *shrug* I definitelyrecommend this place Read more