Reviews for Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza in New Albany, IN

We waited for over 40 minutes to have our pizza made. We were told they had to make the orders ahead of ours. There were times... there was noone else in the store. I watched numerous people walk in place an order and walk out with their pizza and we werestill waiting. If you want a pizza in a timely manner, go somewhere else! Not enough staff that know what they are doing! Itis because of service like this that these stores eventually shut. Great pizza... Horrible managing of this store! Read more

Walked up at 7:48. Website said they close at 8. The two workers just stared at me as I came up to the door and tried to pull it... open. Really wanted some pizza tonight. Guess it will be papa John?s. Read more

Tasty food. Good service. Price is right.

My family loves this place, either pick up or doordash

Its better than FROZEN and most of the time it more consistent than Dominos Papa John's and Pizza Hut. The customer service was... great and she was patient with all my extra questions lol! Read more

The shared parking lot with Chick Fillet was a disaster and the service time was slow. The pizza was less than mediocre. Ive had... better from Kroger and Walmart for HALF the price. Read more

Yeah, I guess this place works if you don't want to do delivery for some reason. The toppings were satisfactory and they do... have a few different styles you won't find at your standard delivery. But the longest recommended cooking time is 18 minutes,which wasn't even close to getting the pizza done. I ended up transferring the pizza to a stone to get some level of crispinessand browning. I would have loved to have done that first, but the dough is premade and was adhered to the paper tray it cameon. So it took over 30 minutes to get the pizza to where the crust was tolerable and at $15 each they were more expensive thandelivery. So they were more expensive, took as long as delivery to cook, and the taste was decent. So for me they really weremore work than they were worth. I could see myself going back here if I wanted to get one of their more unique flavors, but ifI'm going to do carry out, I'd be more likely to go to another famous pizza carry out place. Read more

$5 Friday (at the time of this review) is AMAZING! Same price as little ceasers but IMHO I like this better and it was the first... time having Papa Murphy's. Got 2 pepperoni pizzas and cheese bread (again on $5 Friday) I was in and out in under 3 minutessince it was already made I guess being the day. I did take a star off and made it 4 since the staff just seemed 'blah'. No realhappiness was felt while inside. Almost like no one enjoyed being there. BUT the main part is the food which again was AMAZINGfor the price. Read more