Reviews for Mellow Mushroom New Albany in New Albany, OH
Food was absolutely delightful. Oven fresh pizzas and piping hot wings. We had the mushroom pizza and house and they had their... own unique delicious pallets. It did take a while for the food to come but it's worth it. We were nearly done eating and ourwaitress did not offer any more drinks or refills on our practically empty water and took quite a bit of time to get the checkfrom us. Read more
Wow! We?re locals but this was our first time trying MM. Definitely won?t be our last. Let me start by saying our server,... Daniel, was fantastic! Very personable & attentive. The Cloud 9 wings & Kosmic Karma pizza were AMAZING. Five stars. We?ll beback! Read more
Friendly staff, fun atmosphere, and good food. Double baked garlic parmesan wings may be some of my favorite! Pizza was great... too, fresh ingredients. Will be back again. Update: brownie is really good too Update 2: tried the double oven baked hot wingstoday, very good Read more
Decor is really cool. Tables were a little dirty, kinda grossed me out. The cloud 9 wings were actually really really tasty.... Loved the garlic parm sauce on them. The kozmic karma pizza was very different than what I expected, the classic crust is alsoso puffy and not too crisp that my toppings kept sliding off as I ate. That was annoying. The crust itself though was sogood! Our server was kind of MIA for a good chunk of our dining, which is also why I took away another star. Read more
This was a full salad according to the New Albany Mellow Mushroom location. About three pieces of lettuce and the bowl 80%... empty. My wife's spinach salad was no more full than this as well. I guess this is how they are saving money in the era ofrecord setting inflation. Passing their "savings" onto the customer. Read more
We went to a family lunch here for the first time for all of us. We ordered two appetizers, the Cloud Nine wings and the avocado... smash with bruschetta and toast points. The wings were twice baked, now that being said, they were amazing. The sauce of garlicparm was thick and delicious, parmesan cheese coated everything. The only way they would have better is to be properly fried.The avocado smash was the favorite. The toast points were on punto. The avocado smeared over the buttery toast and topped withbruschetta definitely warmed up the appetite. For our pizza we tried the Havana Affair. It was truly a uniqur experience. Thecrust was a fresher, crispy, chewy ny style, but better. The toppings were amazing and created a taste we have never had before.There was jerk chicken, salami, diced pickles, two kinds of cheese and a mayo mustard drizzle over the top. Everyone of us lovedit. My oldest cried eating it, said it was beautiful. We will definitely be back. Trying the hummus appetizer and getting a halfmushroom special with half meats next time. Cannot wait. Read more
Love this establishment. Great for a family lunch or an evening of craft flights & music. The service is outstanding. Everyone... on staff seems to really care if you're happy. Wow, the food....this is what P&P wish they were. Amazing crust for all the pizzaoptions. Chewy, firm, crunchy & golden. Huge topping assortment with lots of variety in all toppings. The prices aresurprisingly low/affordable for the quality. *The owner was a regular in a retail shop I used to manage. He's an awesome dude.Always friendly and respectful. :) * Read more
The food here is amazing, and it's my favorite of the Mellow Mushroom locales in central Ohio for that reason. The staff is... super friendly, accommodating, and attentive. The veganized holy shiitake is my regular order here. The others have liked theThai Dye pizza and the buffalo chicken version. That being said, they always mess up one of our orders, and we often end upwaiting a good 30+ minutes extra for one of our dishes. The servers and managers have always taken care of us when there hasbeen a mixup in the kitchen, and they discount our order, so we keep coming back here despite the drive, but if you have plansafterwards, keep possible delays in mind. Read more