Reviews for The Eagles Villa Pizza in New Albany, OH
Been meaning to try Eagles for a couple of years and finally did so tonight. The best pizza that I've had in a long time. My son... has already declared it his favorite. Definitely the best meatball sub in town. Can't wait to order from here again. Read more
I?ve ordered pizza from here a few times & they never let me down. Highly recommend.. 5stars
Fantastic pizza my first trip here was the taco pizza, the third (in the picture the BBQ chicken with extra chicken). The pizza... is awesome and the people have been super friendly in my three visits. Eagles is a must go to, if you like pizza! Read more
The pizza is really good and consistent but.... This is the last time I order from here. 2 of the 3 things we ordered were... completely wrong. This happend the last time also. Just glad there is more options moving in the area. I ordered fish no firesand side of mushrooms the pic is what I got. Read more
Eagles is a nice family pizza joint with a variety of options I didn?t love the pizza her but my family did it was very saucey... but I loved everything else there it has a great atmosphere of war monuments. It?s a great place to head for dinner we got apizza burger and salad and they were all delicious. Will definitely come back Read more
I tried Eagles Pizza for the first time last night. Maybe I caught them on a bad night (Friday at 4:30 pm) as my pizza did NOT... live up to the reviews. 1. Crust: no flavor and the texture was hard/crunchy like it wasn't fresh. 2. Sauce (as shown in mypicture) I ordered extra sauce and it was fairly bland and disappointing. 3. Toppings: the sausage is the same non-Italiantasting, ground into little pieces of bland balls you can get at most Central Ohio Pizza joints. The pepperoni was good andprobably the only redeeming quality on the entire pie. Chicken wings: I wanted to try their bone-in chicken wings but they wereout. So I asked for their boneless chicken wings but they were out as well. To be out of wings at 4:30 pm early on a Fridayevening either indicates poor inventory management, that the menu options are not very popular with customers or they might bethe most amazing wings and they sold out before the Friday dinner rush. I do not know. Either way I had to drive to anotherpizza place to buy wings for my wife. Ordering: phone order and timely pickup was very good and the gentleman who served me atthe counter was exceptionally friendly. There's too many pizza options in the surrounding area for me to rush back. It wasdisappointing as I've heard such stellar reviews. Read more
I had a chance to try this place out the other day and I absolutely loved it. I am a big fan of this style of pizza which I... would call regional to Ohio. Their sauce was on par and their crust was excellent. Overall the entire experience was wonderfuland I will definitely go back. I did have a chance to try their spaghetti as well and was not impressed but to be fair I don'tlike spaghetti that well. The only time I eat it is when we make it at home and I make homemade sauce. They're sauce tasted likeit was out of a can and it was really less desirable. I will say that their salads were good and they're fried mushroomsdefinitely tasted homemade. Read more
Pizza was decent. They seem to really load up the toppings. The crust really can support the toppings so it ends up being a mess... with your toppings everywhere if you dont fold it. Im a sauce guy, and while there is sauce, you cant taste it because of allthe toppings. In terms of service you kinda seat yourself and get your own drinks. They bring the pizza out to you but thereisn't like table service. Not the worst but not the best i've had here. Read more