Reviews for On The Bay Boutique, Bar & Cafe in New Baltimore, MI

Everyone is friendly and welcoming, from management(owners?) To the fabulous Michelle, our waitress. Michelle was perfection,... but no less than 3 other staff members stopped by to check on us and chat for a second. You definitely feel special here! Foodwas pretty good, and drinks were tasty! Not even near our neighborhood but we'll be back! And the cutest store to shop in whenyour done with dinner, loved it! Read more

Very cute patio area with plenty of shaded options as well as spots in the sun. My server, Brooke, was very kind and attentive.... I started with the bloody mary (they also offer a loaded option) and it was tasty. For lunch I ordered the lobster roll, whichcame with the option of pasta salad or pineapple coleslaw. The pasta salad was pretty generic, but nice as a cool side option.However, the lobster roll was delightful. The perfect amount of butter and the sweet Hawaiian roll was a perfect complement tothe richness of the lobster. Finally, I ordered a Sunny Day smoothie to go (pineapple, peach, mango, piña colada and mangomix). The smoothie was fruity and tropical and very thick. Next time I would opt to have it made with coconut milk. Read more

**Edit to add: This is my 2nd time visiting from FL and now I make it a point to stop here and eat the lobster roll…it’s... soooo good on the sweet Hawaiian roll. Highly recommend!** Amazing food and drinks!! Staff was very accommodating and theoutdoor seating is super fun! Read more

I guess we just had a one off experience compared to others. My husband and I came in around 5:30 and were seated immediately... and took our drink orders. After a few minutes the waitress came back for food orders. It was around 30 minutes of waitresseswalking back and forth to serve other tables but pass by us each time. After that time we had a different waitress come over andgive us our bill before we even received our food. (After waiting a total of 35 min) She apologized saying the kitchen ticketnever printed, and went to have the kitchen speed our food up. I just feel like even if the ticket didn’t print, youconstantly walked by us seeing we had nothing for some time… After we were finished eating it was another 10-15 min beforeanyone came to give us our bill/clean up the table. Overall: food wise, unfortunately, it was just okay. The lobster roll was alittle bit too soggy for me, the pineapple coleslaw was just regular coleslaw (to me at least), my husbands brisket burnt endrice bowl he said, “tasted like something from Kroger microwaved”. In addition, the lobster and shrimp dip was just okay. Iwas really sad because this place is so cute and had such high praises from others. :( On a positive note, the lady at the frontwas very nice as well as the older gentleman. Read more

Oh, wow! What a local gem! This is an unassuming shop front that has a nice patio area out back. They have a full service bar... that makes specialty cocktails and smoothies. And the food... oh, the food! The menu is small and lobster focused, but what theydo they do oh so well. The lobster flat bread is very tasty and the lobster roll is to die for! Large pieces of tender, sweetlobster are served in a super soft roll. An absolute must try!!! Read more

Had a magnificent lunch here! The lobster room was excellent. The lobster Flatbread was also very good. Very eclectic and fun!... Super friendly staff. Owner said hi. Nice and clean. Southall gift shop. Fabulous food and beverages. Will go back soon!!! Read more

What an awesome spot! Cool place with so much in it I can't even tell you and then the food ,seriously it is awesome. Friends... had the Lobster flatbed and I sampled the burnt ends over rice bowl and the chicken mac. Food was fresh and flavorful.Heatedoutdoor seating and the staff was pleasant . We will definitely be back and looking forward to seeing this place flourish! Thatpretzel tho!!!! dude ???? Read more

Looking for some nautical decor and some other home decor. I found this terrific boutique in downtown New Baltimore. They have... a great assortment of items ranging from nautical to other great home items and a nice selection of clothing. Not to forgetthey have a wonderful cafe and bar featuring items from lobster rolls to a wonderful huge pretzel that came with dipping sauces. I enjoyed a wonderful acai smoothie before I left. Ended up purchasing this cool mixer clock for my kitchen and wall clockfor my sunroom. Staff very helpful and friendly. Read more