Reviews for Armeli's Restaurant & Pizzeria in New Berlin, WI

First time here. Staff was nice. Ordered chicken wings to go. Seemed like low quality chicken. Lots of fatty chewy pieces, and... most of the wings had broken bones. Don?t order these. Read more

Good Italian food. Friendly service. Was quiet due to packer game so almost felt like private facility. Have never been... disappointed here over the 20 years I have gone here. Read more

We dined in-great food, great service. We had the gluten free chicken marsala, gluten free penne with marinara and combo plate... and meatballs. (See pics) Updated interior with a cozy feel. The dining area has a fireplace in it-super cute! Outdoor seatingavailable, nice bar and counter height tables. Entrance is wheelchair friendly. Would definitely recommend. BONUS: They havegluten-free pizza and also gluten free dinner options. Read more

The last couple time we were there my husband got the Friday fish fry and I had lasagna. The lasagna was a nice size portion,... tasty and HOT! My husband said that he can never go wrong with the fish fry. When we order pizza we always ask for extrasausage. Makes their pizza even tastier. Sometimes we just don't feel like going out and we want their pizza we'll order itahead and ask for it NOT to be sliced and also have it PAR-BAKED. Then we throw it in the oven 400 degrees for 6 minutes. Walla.....just like you're eating it there. Kathy's a long time server there and is simply the best. :) Thank you! Read more

Decent food, a little overpriced in my opinion. The $18 fish fry (which I?m still not sure is AYCE, that?s not made clear by... the menu or the waitstaff) isn?t great. It has a crunchy breading with a weird seasoning in it. I love fried cod and wouldn?t goout of my way to have it again. My wife had a $38 8oz filet. I had a bite, it was decent with a premium filet price. (Theyclaim it?s prime, but I found it to be a bit chewy for a ?prime? cut). Waitstaff was friendly, prompt service, I just didn?tcare for the food. Read more

This is a quiet Italian place right on national avenue in New Berlin. They remodeled at some point in the last few years so it?s... a nicer vibe on the inside for sure. Very cute silverware chandelier in the front entryway! On this trip my husband got his ownpizza so he had leftovers for lunches?he liked the pizza. It wasn?t like the best he?s ever had, but it was good! I?m on keto tolose more than a few unwanted pounds so I bypassed the pizza and went with their blackened cod. Yes?it was $17. But it was SOOOGOOD. They give you two roughly 5 oz chunks of cod, so I was able to eat the one and take the other home. Even the next dayreheating it in the microwave for a minute was all it needed and it was just as good day2. It?s a quiet place, has a small barattached you can drink in while you wait and you get bread and butter at the table. Read more

Great food!! Great staff! Our server Cassie was awesome! Front hostess was kind and friendly. Thanks Mia!

Ordered a 3 Topping Pizza and Fettuccine Alfredo. Service was excellent. Light music playing in background. Very Relaxing. I... am so full. Excellent Food. Will come back here if we can. Wait staff very outgoing and friendly. Read more