Reviews for Crossroads II Pizza & Subs in New Berlin, WI
I stop at least once weekly to crossroads for lunch, where they sell pizza by the slice. Great pizza, reasonable prices, and I'm... always in and out within 2-3 minutes. Highly recommended lunch quick-stop for passers by. Read more
Haven?t had Crossroads in a while, and with the Beloit road construction going on, it is a bit more challenging to get there,... BUT? Wife was coming from the other direction and decided to stop in, order a pizza and wait for it. She was told it would take20 minutes, and when she popped back inside after 20 minutes, the pie was ready to go. She ordered a house (thin) crust cheese,sausage, onion, half black olives and half green olives?and man o man it was delicious! Crust was crispy on the edges, chewierin the center, cheese was a perfect golden brown and the toppings were HEAPING!! We have always had consistently good food fromCrossroads. That?s why I just don?t understand the bad reviews stating burned or undercooked food and rude or bad service. Wehave always had good friendly service there, and for me, that says a lot since it is a young crowd that usually works there.They are very friendly, responsible and mature. That alone keeps us coming back! Read more
One of our favorite places for pizza, the only reason I didn't give five stars is because the garlic bread was very greasy and... didn't have much flavor. Read more
I was nervous after reading other reviews, but we drive right by this restaurant on the way home so we gave it a try. We had a... hand tossed pizza; crust was baked perfectly, toppings and cheese were toasty and great. The garlic bread was basic but madevery well. Will definitely return. Read more
We have been ordering pizza from here for almost 30 years and have always found it to be satisfactory. However, about the last... five times we have ordered, the pizza was terrible. The crust was black on the bottom and tasted burned yet the toppings werewatery and appeared uncooked. You couldn't possibly eat the middle of the pizza, it was awful. We kept ordering because it is alocal business and we wanted to support it but after five tries, we are done. The prices are high and that is fine if the foodis high quality but the current product is definitely not worth the price. Perhaps new management or new ovens would make adifference. Something has to change! Read more
First time having pizza from this location in many years and I have to say I was very disappointed. The sauce seemed like it was... mostly tomato paste. The overall flavor wasn?t good either. We had sausage and pepperoni and those seemed very low quality. Wewill not be going back. Read more
Use to love this pizza, last two times I ordered house crust is thin and rock hard not like used to be for 20 years. NO SAUCE... rock hard and terrible not worth 25$ Read more
Monday 10-31 pulled up ,went in , placed order waited in car in parking lot . Pizza was delivered to my car.