Reviews for Not Joe Average Bakehouse & Deli in New Berlin, WI

My wife and I stopped in for some morning donuts and they were delicious! Highly recommend the cake donuts. The other food... looked great as well, we will definitely be back. Read more

Incredible experience yesterday morning as I had heard of this bakery on Facebook. I know they bake gluten free items on... Wednesday but I could not make it that day and was fortunate that a few items were still available on Thursday morning. Ipurchased gluten free chocolate chip cookies, key lime pie cheesecake and an amazing brownie with frosting - it was incredible.I spoke with one of the owners, Amanda and she shared her story of how this really great new bakery came alive. They offerregular bakery and deli items and gluten and vegan free bakery items as well. Stop in and check out this great new establishmentand meet one of your neighbors living the American dream. Read more

An amazing addition to the community! The Owners do a fantastic job and could not be more friendly and welcoming. Every time my... boyfriend and I go, we can?t help but scoop up some of the to die for taco dip and some sweets!! We tried the 9 inch donut forthe first time this week and OH. MY. GOSH. One of the best cake donuts I?ve ever had. Overall excellent place. Will be returningtime and time again. Read more

Just stopped in for the first time today. Surprised to see how busy it was, but I can see why. You are welcomed with great... customer service, mouthwatering bakery items immediately catch your eye as you walk in and the vintage decor is a cute addition.Bought some coffee which was self serve and not to mention a great price. I will definitely be back to try more treats on mynext visit. If you want to help out a local family owned business, I highly recommend this place! Read more

Went in to support a local business and because I had heard great things. I didn\'t find the place to be particular warm and... welcoming. The customers were more talkative and kind than the employees. The paper order system is wasteful. Using a full pieceof paper for each sandwich/salad order is a bit much. Lots of options though, which is nice. I ordered ham, but didn\'t get anyon my sandwich. My girls did get plenty of pepperoni on theirs though. They also stated they didn\'t have any 7 inch baguettes,only 10. When we got home they looked very small for 10 and my daughter decided to measure them. Of the 3, the longest was 8,the shortest 7. I don\'t know if there is a cost difference because there was only a price listed for 7 and 12. A bit pricey,but homemade and local does cost (I just wish I had gotten my ham). The sandwiches were good. The ability to get watermelonslices was great. My daughters also enjoyed their churros. Read more

A delicious, locally-owned delight. Their donuts are amazing (there were more donuts in the white box pictured, but I couldn\'t... resist eating one before writing this review!), and they have a NINE INCH DONUT! I\'ll have to try that sometime soon. I brieflymet one of the owners. Him and the other workers seem friendly. This has now become one of my favorite places. I will mostlikely become a regular customer! Read more

Great new spot in town! We were greeted by such a warm welcome and introduction to their team by a lovely older lady. The place... is decorated so cute- the bakery all looks delicious and the candy section is amazing! We ordered a chopped salad, build yourown sandwich and the homemade pasta salad- food was all fantastic! We?ll be back! Read more

I love this place! I Stopped in to support a new and local family owned business and was very impressed. The owners are so... welcoming and have done a fabulous job transforming this property into an inviting and beautiful bakery and deli! Today Ipurchased a \"bakers dozen\" of super fresh, delicious donuts! I enjoyed a cup of coffee while i browsed the shop. There aremany nostalgic items on display, including a vintage candy bar. I look foward to returning to try the deli items and more bakedgoods. Read more