Reviews for Calahan's Pub and Pizza in New Braunfels, TX

Got a simple pepperoni pizza and 2 pizza rolls. The pizza and the roll weren?t cooked through. Both were still doughy but the... pizza rolls were so undercooked we didn?t eat them the pizza was just chewy. Also supposed to get two sauces with your rolls andthen We ordered two extra. So supposed to have 4 sauces only received one. And side note the spicy marinara is just marinarawith hot sauce added. Photo is from after we put them in our oven for awhile. Read more

Pizza rolls are huge and puffy, stuffed with cheese and pepperoni, and will having you coming back to satisfy that craving. The... cheese pizza, a classic the showcases the great dough recipe, and the cheese is flavorful and layered perfectly. I also rave onthe Chicken Alfredo pizza, as the robust savory flavors and buttery crust makes you want more. It does take about 30-60 minutesfor you pizza to be made fresh, but the wait is absolutely worth it! This is my second time back. Read more

Hands down not only the best pizza in downtown New Braunfels, but overall in the city. Ordered a thin crust butcher block with... mushrooms. Served up quickly and fresh from the oven. Definitely a great bar to check out on your next trip to the river. Read more

Phenomenal pizza joint. Tried it and it didn't disappoint. Food was absolutely amazing. Service was great and food came out fast... and hot. I highly recommend you come stop by and taste greatness. Definitely considering moving into the area now. Read more

Their drinks and service are good. I liked the pizza rolls a lot. The lime they put in my margarita was bitter and strange... tasting but I still enjoyed the margarita. The one thing about this place is that a double of liquor costs $25, which isinsane. They also don?t give you an itemized bill so you get handed your extremely expensive check and have no idea why it costsso much. I?ll be coming back here for the food but not the drinks Read more

The food is five stars, amazingly five stars. We weren?t sure what to expect, but we ordered a Butcher Block w/mushrooms... because we are fun guys. Between three eaters, this pizza didn?t stand a chance. Read more

Pleasantly surprised with the pizza and atmosphere. Full bar as well (pub)! In my opinion best Pizza pub in the area. Next pizza... will be Calahan's. Read more

Such a yummy change of pace from the main chains. The pizza is delicious and we love the pizza rolls. A few times the rolls... haven't been thoroughly cooked, with raw dough in the middle however this isn't always the case (as with the picture below).When they are cooked properly it is 100% the best pizza rolls ever. Their house made ranch is amazing. Read more