Reviews for Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels in New Braunfels, TX

We have been ordering takeout and delivery (hallelujah!) from Mattenga's since they opened this new location. We love the pizza... crust and interesting varieties of toppings and combinations. We love the unusual dressings that they have available also! Wehave ordered pizza rolls, brisket rolls, calzones, pizza, salads, desserts-- we haven't had a bad meal yet. Service is alwaysprompt and friendly. We are so thankful that Mattenga's delivers to us, since we are in Vintage Oaks and when we moved inOctober 2021 _not a single pizza place_ would deliver. Thank you, Mattenga's! Read more

Having traveled all over the US, Mattenga's is one of the best pizzas we've had! Outstanding customer service is just a bonus... and if you have the opportunity to be served by Parker, you'll know! He's not only an obvious hustler in the kitchen but isquick to serve you as a customer! Can't recommend enough if you're in the area! Read more

Wish I would have taken a picture of the food but the family was too quick eating it! Pizza was awesome... cooked... perfectly. The Brisket Roll rocked. The pretzels were perfect. I ordered pick up and it was ready in 15 minutes and the staffwas great. This is now my favorite pizza place in the area! Read more

I tried out Mattenga's randomly and I have to say it was really good pizza. The only thing I would recommend to Mattenga's is... you really need a better drink station. I would highly recommend if you happen to be craving pizza while you are out and about. Read more

This is probably best as a take-out only place. We tried this for the first time last night and agree that the pizza was good,... maybe even some of the better pie in town, but they?re not set up for dine-in or for hosting guests. *Three tables *no way toget water or refill a drink (Ice is behind the counter and requires the checker to put down her phone to refill) *full 30-minutewait for pizza *Salad (brought in prepackaged plastic box for twice the price of any other place in town) at the same time thepizza box was dropped on the table. (Salad was also not made as ordered.) *Styrofoam plates and plastic silverware rounded outour experience. Again, not an issue if you take out, but as a patron, it?s not a great experience. Listening to the checkerchat on the company phone and/or play on her phone while someone is waiting to ask for a refill put a bad taste in ourmouths. Good pizza, below average dining experience Read more

This is our third attempt with this place and the results have been the same . Staff is great . Our pizza always seems... overcooked and taste like it is frozen pizza out of the box. I would just give a 1 star, but the staff deserves another fortheir friendliness Read more

This place is so delicious. The pizza rolls are some of the best we've ever had. I had the margherita pizza and it was... delicious. Super friendly staff and it came out quickly. Read more

Great pizza! It came out quick and it was nice and hot. It had a great flavor and we'll def order again!