Reviews for The Reel Seafood & Grill in New Braunfels, TX

Food was pretty good. Just wish the fondue wouldn't of been so watery. Confused on the long wait to get our deserts. Other thing... was since we were right by the door for the patio. It was a pain since the servers wouldn't shut the doors when they wentthrough. Read more

Went here for brunch on a Sunday and enjoyed the outdoor seating. I had the stuffed flounder which was delicious! Initially I... thought it was kind of small, but it was decently stuffed and so was I after eating it. My husband and youngest kid had gumbowhich they enjoyed. My mom had blackened catfish which she too enjoyed. The rice looked bland and the beans were slightlyovercooked in my opinion. My daughter had french toast which looked and tasted delicious per her report. My son’s burger was alittle thin, and he didn’t eat it all as he normally would. Overall we enjoyed the restaurant and the service was very good.The prices were reasonable. Feeding 4 adults, a teen, and 1 kid ran us $160. Will definitely return when in the area. Read more

The Reel Seafood & Grill was a pleasant experience. We sat on the patio. Our waiter was professional and competent, caring for... several tables and neglecting none. I had the Redfish Jambalaya and my wife the Citrus Glazed Salmon, both were good choices.Plan on $30 entrees; a moderate price for a very good evening. Read more

Loved this place!!!! It was me and a friends first time and from beginning to end was fantastic. I believe we had Tana as our... waitress? Super friendly, gave a great recommendation to start with the fondue….was more than happy to get a dog bowl for ourfriend Monty who joined us. The oysters were BOMB, just overall we had a great time there. Especially on a beautiful day liketoday but she was very attentive and lovely. I wrote on her receipt I hope she has a great rest of the week because showing yourappreciation can go a long way for somebody in their line of work. We will def be coming back to try their grilled chicken pastaand other happy hour drinks :) Thank you so much again! Read more

Another great place that goes under the radar. From the outside, it doesnt look like much but the cooks can throw down! I had... the Red fish Jambalaya and it is on Point! Large portion of Fish, shrimp, crawfish,, roux and rice! It did not disappoint! Myhusband had the lunch portion Fish and shrimp Tacos. This dish comes with Two Tacos and they allowed with no additional fee tomake one Shrimp and one Fish. We didn't upgrade to the $6 Mahi Mahi but will be giving that a try the next go. We did have toask for bread and butter. It use to come while you waited but this time I noticed that the customers had to request it. TheSweet tea isn't too sweet, it's just right. It is quite pricey but I say it is worth it. The Redfish Jambalaya was big enoughfor two people to share. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. In this heat, we chose inside but I am sure it is a nicespot in the evening. Read more

Celebration of Mother’s Day for my mom and wife. Enjoyed the Seafood Fondue, Calamari, Chicken Pasta, margaritas, fried fish... and shrimp. All delicious. Claire took care of us. Great quality. Thank y’all. Read more

Appearance- clean, friendly, cozy. Outside seating. Hostess- one friendly,  helpful, professional... one,  not so much. ... Chewing gum, (open mouth chewing smacking), shugging shoulders rolling eyes,  not professional. Waitress- friendly, attentive,  respectful. Ordered- house margarita,  water, dozen oysters (only had the more expensive ones), citrus salmonworth house salad (in house homemade blue cheese dressing). Margarita was what was expected for a house drink during happyhour. Salad was good,  blue cheese dressing was good. Oysters were good smaller than the "big" ones advertised in the menu, but the flavor made up for the size. Samon- cooked medium set on asparagus- great flavor!  Even though the asparagus waslarge,  it was grilled and tender. Portion was big enough to fill me up. Five states, even with the hostess smaking gum. (Shewas not my hostess or if have to go 4 starts) Food and experience was worth theprice, even with the more pricey menu. Read more

It was surprising how good this place was. My hubby wanted grilled fish for lunch (you know - to be “healthier”) and they... delivered! The Almost Crusted Redfish was beyond delicious and neither one of us are huge fish eaters! The texture and flavorwere amazing. The buerre blanc sauce made the entire dish. The fried shrimp where also tasty - lightly breaded, split andcrunchy. The only downside is we went on a Sunday and the lunch menu was only available during the weekdays. The prices were atad steep for us so we will just need to plan to go on the weekdays in the future. Read more