Reviews for The Buffet New Buffalo in New Buffalo, MI

We went on Friday, November 19th at 6 pm until 7:30 pm and the place was pretty much deserted. 2 of us for $60 plus tax and tip,... not a bargain buffet. Could have had crab legs for an extra $15 a person but we passed on that. What a letdown! Only the carvingstation open with Prime rib, and kielbasa. Limited same food choices (green beans, corn, mashed potatoes, Broccoli and Beef andgrilled cod and some pizza on either side. Asian, Italian and Mexican station was completely closed. Definitely not value formoney for what they offer. Place had maybe 10% occupancy. No wonder at that price. Any cheap Asian buffet restaurant offers morefor a third of the price. Tried to win back the wasted food money at a card table but was taken there as well. Will cut upplayer card and won't return Read more

Very disappointed. Minimalistic. Pizza, turkey and stuffing, gravy, mashed potatoes, 3 Asian dishes, prime rib, sausage,... possibly pork chops, and fried shrimp. Garlic bread. Chilled shrimp, sushi, salad, bread, soup, cheese and meats,, Gelato anddesserts. Not much of a selection and you could tell that stuff was out for a while. Only saw three chefs total. Meat wasdry, meat and cheese had a sheen to them that they were old. Seafood soup was tasteless. Best part was prime rib and sausagealong with shrimp. Not sure if it was worth 30 bucks a piece. Read more

Omg... we ate one course.. asked were our drinks were.. hostess said be right back with them... after the second course I asked... if there was a water station or something I'm thirsty. Finally about desert time drinks showed up. What a joke..not to mentionthe picture is start to finish of food and plates that never got removed from the table... Read more

I play alot and very rarely eat here. Tonight we celebrated one of our employees going away party. I had 8 of my employees for... diner at the buffet. Worst buffet I have ever ate at. I had two vegetarians in our group and the buffet didn't have any warmveggies including potatoes. There was mash potatoes but they were empty the whole time we were there. They both had a salad. The buffet was literally a carving station and that was it, the prime rib was horrible, the chicken was dry. Great shrimpthough. I wouldn't pay 5 bucks for this buffet. I'm a Gold card member and I was very disappointed. Read more

Worst buffet experience in years. Almost no food . 80 percent of all stations closed. Only a few hot choices plus the salad... bar. Paid 30 for crab legs separate and couldn't take leftover legs home even though I bought them separately. What food theyhad was bad. Service was good but still fine with this buffet for at least next few years. Horrible. Read more

Less than half the stations were open. Sorry but quality of food was minimal. Prime rib was good, fried shrimp was good. Rest of... available food was not worth the cost of buffet. Won't be back and it was one of our favorites Read more

Jail food taste better. Heather the manager was difficult to work with. We barely ate one plate a piece and wouldn't refund 50%... off the meal. Only offered a players club card. I'll expect compensation from someone over her. I'll be in touch. Avoid thisnasty $28 a person buffet. Read more

Normally would rate a 5 but most of the stations were closed my last visit (probably due to covid and staffing). Food was great... and fresh as always. Desserts were yummy. Staff attentive. Read more