Reviews for Kate O'Connor's Irish Pub in New Carlisle, IN
Great pub on the edge of New Carlisle is a an unexpected gem! Simple Irish and American food staples and a classic array of... national and regular beer, complimented with a full bar. Very attentive staff, even when busy. Mostly clean-ish, but could be alittle better. Prices are reasonable, and the taste always hits the spot. Read more
My meal was fine, but the totally messed up my husband's. Forget things, and then gave him some sauce instead of dressing on his... salad. Read more
Found this gem while passing through and had to stop. Place is clean, has a pool table, several screens, and the food menu is... fun. I had these Reuben "egg rolls". Very tasty. Kinda wish they actually played Irish music though. Still, look forward toreturning next time I'm near. Read more
Always have a great experience there. Love the good food. Staff is great!!
My family and I showed up with 18 people (2 babies included) and the staff did a great job not only dealing with a sudden large... party, but the food and drinks came out fast and tasted amazing. They were wonderful and it hope to go again when we are in thearea. Read more
I had high hopes since I heard great things about this place. Honestly the atmosphere was great but the food was horrible. We... got the nachos and it was missing half of the things it listed it would come with. It also tasted odd. Then my party all hadissues with their meals. A simple burger on one the cheese was not melted and the fries and burger were far undercooked. Thefish basket was also undercooked the breading was still soggy as well as the fries. Very disappointed. Read more
We love the charm of Kate O?Connor?s! The authentic pub decor and friendly staff make for an enjoyable experience! I... particularly love the fish & chips with a pint! This is a very nice, well managed establishment for New Carlisle and thesurrounding area! Highly recommend! Read more
Excellent food and service! The soup was out of this world, Irish Potato! Highly recommend!