Reviews for Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe in New Carlisle, OH

My first ever visit to Penny Lane. I had the special for that day, the French dip sandwich. It was absolutely delicious. The... dining room is eclectic and cozy with all the art on the walls that is also for sale. I will definitely be back. Read more

If you?re looking for a new hang-out place to drink your coffee, this is it! I stopped by here for the first time and I was... immediately impressed. The ambience was next level. Plenty of comfortable areas to sit, beautiful art pieces to admire, and agreat menu to choose a drink that speaks to your soul. I?m already looking forward to coming back to try their coffee flights!The menu didn?t mention it so I didn?t know it was a thing until I checked out their Facebook page. GO! You?ll be happy you did! Read more

Delicious soup and sandwich combo. Lots of coffee and teas plus dessert. The staff was very pleasant and helpful. Comfortable... space for dining or just meeting up with friends. You should try it! Read more

Penny Lane is a wonderful coffee shop with excellent breakfast and lunch options. They are courteous, kind and quick. My food... was ready within 10 minutes and it was a big lunch crowd. I?m so glad to have this restaurant locally. Read more

Staff is welcoming, helpful, and efficient. Claudia is our favorite batista, but they all do a great job. All food and drink... we've ever purchased here, dine-in or carry-out, have been delicious. Read more

I've tried many things at Penny Lane and I have yet to try something I didn't like! Their coffee is always delicious, their... sandwiches are always fresh, and their dessert is amazing. All the baristas are so friendly! Read more

We enjoyed the iced latte flight, orange brownie, and the blueberry Danish. It made for a nice Saturday afternoon date.

Upscale decor in a quaint Cafe. Located in downtown New Carlisle, OH, Penny Lane is an unexpected treat. The food is excellent... and the service was prompt and friendly. Read more