Reviews for Cookie Girl Bake Shop in New City, NY
We started using them for our holiday baskets this year. We wanted to support a local business rather than an online catalog. We... were not disappointed! They even were able to deliver locally and ship out to whoever was not local. Super accommodating witheverything. The owner Liz personally helped me and took my order. I also had to try a few things myself after placing the orderand the cookies are out of this world. If you are looking for a simple gift, something to bring to a party or a treat foryourself stop by Cookie Girl! Read more
Obsessed with the M&M cookie !! Got the cake for my birthday this year everyone was amazed ! Fresh ingredients and lots of love... goes into it. A little pricey but worth it ! Will definitely be back and recommend for all!!!! Yum ???? Read more
Thanks Liz for the beautiful basket you made up that I received for Mother?s Day. Not only was the basket so creative and pretty... but the cookies and brownies were so delicious. The packaging was perfect and all the treats arrived safely. Great product andservice. Read more
Best cookie place ever! The staff is incredible! Liz is an artist and everyone there treats you like gold!
Delicious every time
We started using them for our holiday baskets this year. We wanted to support a local business rather than an online catalog. We... were not disappointed! They even were able to deliver locally and ship out to whoever was not local. Super accommodating witheverything. The owner Liz personally helped me and took my order. I also had to try a few things myself after placing the orderand the cookies are out of this world. If you are looking for a simple gift, something to bring to a party or a treat foryourself stop by Cookie Girl! Read more
This place has been locked up tighter than a drum since the start of the pandemic - over two years now. Heavy, dark brown... drapes across all the windows. Only indicator of any activity is a sign that reads, "We're still here!" and another withinstructions for deliveries. Funny how their most recent review from 2 months ago includes interior pictures and is an exactduplicate of another review from 4 years ago. Pretty much all pandemic precautions and mandates have been lifted, ladies. Iwould not even consider patronizing a business that is strictly "curbside only" at this point, especially a type of businessthat is so service-oriented and for which there are plenty of local options to choose from. Open up, or vacate the space andmake it available to someone else. Read more