Reviews for Yellow Tavern in New Harmony, IN
Debet/credit cards not accepted. But ATM in the back with a 5 dollar charge. I got a meat lovers pizza and cheese pizza it had... no flavor sizes were smaller then sizes ordered. I'll NEVER be back. Please don't waste your money. Gas station pizza would be away better choice. Read more
I've had better pizza at gas stations. $31 for frozen pizza is wrong. They don't warn you they refuse debit cards so your forced... to use there atm with a service fee for a worthless meal at a high price. Lesson learned!! Read more
We were camping @ Harmonie State Park & decided to go into town Friday Sep. 16th to have lunch. Six of us got seated & a older... female server came to our table. She wasn?t friendly from the start. It was like she had a chip on her shoulder. One of usasked for ketchup when the food was brought out. After 10 minutes we had to ask again. She acted all put out when weasked. Once the ketchup was brought to our table she said she would get us drink refills since all of our cups were empty. Instead of getting our refills in a timely manner she continued waiting on other tables & wiping off two tables next to us. Iasked her politely if we could get our drink refills when she had a moment. She looked at me & just laughed. After we werefinished with our meals she finally got our refills. Overall the food was average at best & the service was very poor. Won?tever go back. Read more
We went on a holiday weekend. The tavern was the only place open and it was almost completely full. The staff was friendly. ... The food was good. The buisness is cash only, but there is an ATM. Read more
Went to the Yellow Tavern with some friends, there were 6 of us. My wife and I ordered a loaded pizza. Others ordered chili,... they all enjoyed the chili. The pizza was exceptional, the only thing I can say negative is, as I say in most pizza places, notenough sauce. But there's lots of meat and cheese and the crust was thin, the way I like it. One of our party ordered a Ruben,he said it was very good, he loves Ruben sandwiches. He also ordered a baked potato and the baked potato was just about theright size, not too big and was cooked all the way through. Something that everyone needs to understand is that the YellowTavern is just that, a tavern, a bar, so anyone under the age of 21 is not allowed in. We saw several groups of people come inwith children and were told they could not stay. The place is old but has a lot of good character, the help was great, veryhelpful, very friendly, a lot of fun. We had a good time. Read more
Superb lunch in a restored old building in New Harmony, Indiana. Grilled pork tenderloin sandwich with chips. Be advised they... are a CASH ONLY establishment. Read more
My wife has been wanting to take me here for 35 years. We finally made it. I was not disappointed. The pork tenderloin sandwich... was everything that I had heard about. I even got to try a brain sandwich. It was great. I would recommend the Yellow Tavern toanyone! Read more
The service was good and so was the food. I had the Reuben sandwich and it was made correctly and delicious. A lot of... Indiana restaurants do not use the proper cheese and bread. I highly recommend stopping here for a good meal AND good desserts1 Read more