Reviews for Carmella's Cafe in New Hartford, NY
Sarah was the best waitress we have ever had. We had 7 people come in at about 9-9:30 ish. She literally treated us amazing! My... boyfriend and I were in from North Carolina and we had our friends with us. She gave us the best service ever and when we comeback up we will definitely go back for her. She treated us amazing! Read more
Food was excellent, waitress was very kind and accommodating for my food allergies!
Not only was the food amazing but what truly made it was our waitress Margie! This woman deserves a raise and promotion! She is... like real life superwoman! We have an 8month daughter and she was beyond amazing and kind to not only us but her. She treatedevery guest as family ! Gladly come back because of her! Read more
Came into town Mid August took my Gram there for lunch while visiting my Dad in the hospital. My wife and I thank you guys for... the great food Great service friendly staff. The Canoli was to die for! Only regret is I wish I had time go go back for one oftheir awesome antipasto salads! It's so hard to find a good one here in Florida let alone a place that knows what they are. Read more
When you walk in your greeted emediately. The surveys and staff are extremely friendly and helpful. The best part of the food... was the appetizer. The main entre was some of the worst food I've ever had at a resteraunt. The Alfredo is far from creamy thebroccoli is undercooked and entire heads in the Alfredo. Chicken parm is fried so much its black. And you can taste burnthamburger in the lasagna. I'd only go again if I were making appetizers my meal. Very disipointed. Read more
Excellent fresh baked warm bread with seasoned butter! Our waitress, Catie, is absolutely a gem! She got our orders absolutely... perfect, a cheery sweet demeanor, and absolutely kind! I loved how taken care of we were. She was super likeable and great ather job. I hope to come back soon! The food,of course, was phenomenal. Read more
Used to be a huge favorite of mine, but they fell off for a couple years with food quality. Very happy to say that it seems they... are back to their good days. Great food, good deals, excellent staff (blonde waitress with the nose ring was one of the bestwaitresses I've had anywhere in a long time), nice atmosphere. Even when it's fairly busy, which is often, the food is outrelatively quick & the service is good. They often have happy hour specials on drinks and appetizers like buy one get one free.Their fried calamari is one of my favs around. Good choice for a variety of occasions and diners, including just going out fordrinks. Read more
We will be returning. Our waitress Alana was wonderful. Soups were great. Spaghetti was terrible. Hard, dry, lacking salt. It is... reportedly home made. I’m Italian, I made macaroni with my grandmother a lot. Not even close. It was industrial qualitymacaroni. Would stand up to any abuse. And massively overpriced. They tried twice and failed. Everything else was really great!Spaghetti never again. Read more