Reviews for Tony's Pizzeria in New Hartford, NY
Zero stars!!! I called ordered my pizza went there about 30 minutes later. They never made it! Apparently, their ?system? loses... orders? No accountability on their behalf. Just rudeness! Plus, I?ve noticed that they never respond to reviews. Sounprofessional. NEVER GO OR ORDER FROM HERE! Read more
My husband and I went to Tony's to attend a comedy show inside of Fat Katz Comedy Club. The show had a minumum of 2 items per... person, but since we ate dinner before hand, we ordered drinks, mozarella sticks and cheescake. The food was fine and wait staffwas attentive. I am taking one star away for the cleanliness of the bathrooms, that had questionable smears on the walls. Theymay need a good scrubbing. Read more
Food is delicious and figner licking good????
We went for the spaghetti and meatball special on Thursday's. It was 6.99. They gave us more pasta than we could eat and 2 large... meatballs ! It was very good. We also ordered the garlic bread which was huge and delicious and only 2.25 ! The lady that servedus was wonderful and so nice ! Would recommend trying this ! Read more
Pizza was hot and tasted good but they forgot to add the chicken. I called to complain but they said that the chicken was cooked... under the cheese. We are almost through the pizza and we are yet to find a piece of chicken. The chicken club sub had a littlemarinara sauce but otherwise it was mostly flavorless. Read more
Just ordered pizza and wings & the pizza was inedible. You can see in the picture the crust is so thin and dry it was cracking.... Tasted like gritty cardboard. We have ordered from here numerous times, not sure if there has been a recent change in ownershipbut it feels as though they stuck a frozen pizza in the microwave and charged $12 for it. Wings were okay, but not at all thequality we are used to. Read more
Two (see below for why 1 star) stars because it was edible but we probably shouldn't have. We arrived at a friend's house from... Las Vegas tonight on our trip across country and wanted some good NY pizza and wings. We ordered a large pepperoni, 30 wings anda large salad. Price quoted was over 80$. We cancelled the wings and price over $30. Whoever took the order could've mentionedtheir special is a large two topping pizza and 30 wings for $38 but didn't. So we called back and change the order. In Las Vegaswhen you order wings, ranch or blue cheese is included but I guess not here. They didn't even offer to sell me some when I askedif they were included. When we got home and I opened the salad there was a clump of hair and I don't know what else attached tothe hair. See picture attached. We called to inform them of this problem and after a few minutes of back and forth because Ididn't take my receipt with me. They finally said they would credit my credit card for the cost of the food. Now as for thequality of the pizza, wings and salad, we were not impressed at all. The pizza was okay. The wings were way too salty and toomuch breading. The salad was average. I look forward to getting home to tell our local pizza joint that their $5 pizza is betterthan a New York pizza. If you read this I would highly recommend you find another pizza joint or maybe you like having this kindof experience. I was told they would refund me but they didn't so they earn a 1 star. Read more
Two (2) sodas at the bar...$7.00??? ????????. Usually, soda is free refills!! It is free refills on the pizzeria side! Lesson... to be learned...don't order soda from the bar!! Great wings though! Excellent pizza from John!! Read more