Reviews for Goodfellas Restaurant in New Haven, CT
New haven restaurant week menu selection more so than many others.. enjoyed the filet cognac with portobello mushrooms and... shrimp.. oysters delicious.. recommended chalk hill pinot noir was very good.. Read more
Waiter very nice and made several food suggestions. Appetizers were good. Hi My friend and I ordered for dinner the Bronzini Sea... Bass. Unfortunately it was not fresh and had a fishy smell and taste. Also several tiny bones I had to pick out. Definitely notworth the price that we paid. My husband enjoyed his pork chop. Read more
Went for a private business dinner...much better this time. Food was fantastic although the potatoes still taste instant the... rest was delish. Bartender Jacob was so knowledgeable. Service was great. Read more
First time, and restaurant week. It was a fabulous experience, and I would absolutely come back again. Great atmosphere,... fabulous food, and our server was attentive and went above and beyond with a couple mishaps we had experienced. Read more
The entrees were good- appetizers dessert and service sucked! Never had such poor quality at an Italian restaurant. We had to... ask for water, a steak knife, and for help from other waitstaff as our waiter was MIA. See pictures below. Read more
I love Goodfellas. The food is always great! French martini Apple martini *Calamari *Fried eggplant stacked with mozzarella... tomato and a light of drizzle balsamic *Atlantic salmon with diced vegetables *Stuffed shrimp with roasted vegetables and mashedpotatoes *Red velvet cheesecake *Chocolate cupcake with vanilla ice cream Read more
5/26/2018 I know this is weird, but what do they do to the butter here? It was soooo dang good. I know better than to load up... on bread before I eat, but I really couldn't help myself. The bread was warm and the butter was amazing lol. Overall the disheswere delicious and affordable. I had the Eggplant Rollatini and the Swordfish. My daughter had the Roasted Vegetables & ChickenRollatini. The Eggplant was heavenly! I've never had Swordfish before, so I don't have anything to compare it to. The flavorwas good, but towards the middle the fish was a little mushy. Not a complaint, because I have no idea what the consistency issupposed to be. My daughter said her chicken didn't quite live up to her expectations, but still enjoyed it. (She had had thedish a few months prior at the same location.) The roasted veggies had a superb, uncomplicated & subtle flavor. We both enjoyedthem immensely. The waitstaff was impeccably attentive & courteous. I enjoyed our visit and will definitely be returncustomer. *Cross Posted to Yelp* Read more
My husband and I celebrated our 11th wedding anniversary and it was our first time here. The atmosphere was nice - holds true to... the Goodfellas theme! Our waiter and hostess were very nice. The food portions were large and very good. I had the Lobsterravioli and my husband had the Chicken Cordon blue. We enjoyed our meal and our time together. We'll definitely come back again! Read more