Reviews for PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack in New Holland, PA
In my opinion this place has the best tasting pizza & chicken cheese steak sub in new holland my food is always fresh and the... workers are always nice ! Read more
I?m unsure why there?s so many cheesesteak accolades, as the 2 I got were literally dry meat with a piece of melted American on... a plain bun. I?m more of a loaded cheesesteak guy so meh. The meat lovers pizza looks and tastes great. The buff chick pizza wasa sloppy mess. Reminded me of soup. BUT, great portions for price, the food tastes good, my subs came with fries included, andthe Italian subs was great. Watch for unexplained 10$ ?price adjustments? to be added to your finalized bill tho.. Read more
I tried calling in a big order over $100 worth of food 24 hours ahead of time for a party. The girl on the phone tells me it?s... not possible. Never heard of a small business turning down a big order like that so I was shocked. They have taken big ordersfrom me before. To me it sounded more like laziness from the worker rather than not being able to do it. I?m sure the ownerwould not have turned it down. I can say that I love their pizza especially the taco pizza!!!!! Amazing!!! I won?t stop goinghere and still recommend them but this left a really bad taste in my mouth and I won?t be calling for any other parties becauseI need someone reliable. Read more
Im never the type to do this but this really irritated me. Come on guys I know you're better than this. I order for myself and a... coworker. His food, perfect. Even made the fries extra crispy the way he likes and everything. I specifically ask for vinegarand oil on my sub and I get mayo anyway. So I scrap it off and deal with it. Then I get to my onion rings and I find they'renowhere close to as crispy as his fries but whats worse is there was a hair in the batter. Not cool guys. Feel like I could'vetaken my 30 bucks elsewhere. Read more
We love coming here, everything is typically great! However, last night we ordered and it seems as if they rushed through our... order. The pizza wasn't cooked completely the dough was undercooked and all of the cheese wasn't even melted. The mozzarellasticks weren't done completely either. Hopefully things are back to how they use to be next time we order Read more
We 2 for 3 deal. That's two 18" cheesesteaks for three hungry people. We got one traditional and one buffalo chicken. So that's... 36" of sandwich for 3 people yummy! Read more
Great food and customer service. It has new a owner as of a few months ago, who is typically there, and will take care of you! ... They have some great lunch specials and a nice deck out front for outdoor seating. I'd highly recommend checking this place out! Read more
I bought a dozen 18in cheese steaks for my guys at work and they all loved it.