Reviews for Gino's Trattoria & Pizzeria of New Hyde Park in New Hyde Park, NY

Was feeling under the weather after Thanksgiving so I had soup. YOU MUST TRY THE FISH SOUP! Delicious and satisfying. Calamari... and shrimp with a very tasty broth that had a subtle kick. Every spoonful gathered something. Try it! Read more

Pretty solid pizza but garlic knots are kinda expensive.

Good food nice selection only issue I have is when you order an entree and it comes with pasta. The pasta you can literally... count on the plate. A box of pasta costs $1 and you?re giving pasta where you count the pieces. You can do better than that!!! This time my wife had Chicken Marsala and the sauce was reddish brown not your usual deep brown color was also thin and nottasty We mentioned this to the owner and after taking my money stated he would speak to the cook what should have happened wasspeak with the cook first and even ask to see the leftovers with the sauce and then ask for the money Not looking for a freemeal in any way shape or form but for $22 make the customer feel that you?re genuinely sorry this happened plus after thewaitress delivered the meal to he table we never saw her again until we asked for the check that?s right we asked for the checknot the other way around Read more

Love it. It?s a big slice of pizza with load of meat and cheese. Big plate with reasonable price i would say.

Horrible service and customer service. Ordered cheesecake received soggy cake tasted very similar to key lime pie. Slice was... placed upside down and packaged that way. Would never order from them again. Called in to notify staff of my dissatisfactionand was rudely interrupted. Read more

This was my first time here, the pizza was fine. Nothing that's gonna blow your socks off but safe. I had regular, pepperoni,... and chicken marsala. Everything tasted good. Crunch was good, though on the marsala slice the bottom was very soggy. I guess itis kind hard to have a crunchy bottom with such a heavy topping. But I enjoyed it. Will most likely come back. Read more

Amazing food, parking is tuff. But well worth it. Appetizers was some of the best fried Diablo calamari I?ve had in a while. So... delicious. Main course was amazing, Rigatoni ala Gino?s was insane! This dish was bursting with flavor, the chicken and sausagewas succulent and moist. The all vodka sauce was perfect. And the mozzarella tasted like it was just made. Very impressed. Thesalmon and vegetable was an enormous dish. It was enough for 2. Very fresh. And the staff and waitress were very polite andprofessional, Kim & Mayra were so sweet and made the whole experience perfect. The desert was the final icing on the cake. TheTirimusi was heavenly. The whole experience was great until we found out that the owner didn?t allow us to Tip! Veryunfortunate. I give the food. service and staff A+ but the fact the owner doesn?t allow people to tip is very disappointing.Especially around the Holidays... Read more

Great location with good food. Portions are generous. Pricing is comparable to restaurants of the caliber. It should be given a... full five stars. However, service wasn't perfect. Some of the employees just went about their business leaving is hangingwondering where to sit for more than 10 minutes. However, once seated, our server was phenomenal. Maybe they were busy? All inall, a great gem. Read more