Reviews for Casey's in New Lebanon, OH
Cases os what every gas station/convenience store ahould aspire to. High ceilings so you dont feel like you are entering a... cave...and organized and spacious aisles so you dont feel like you will be robbed at any minute and can actually find what youneed to get. Great customer service too...its like...they actually know they are a service and treat people the right way...thisis at every caseys ive been to, from here in ohio to owensboro ky. Read more
Spend on the average 100 dollars a week used to be a friendly place to go however here lately the cashier has been really rude... and hateful. I understand people can have a bad day but it has become a pattern I really dont want to take my business elsewherebut I will if manager doesn't fix the problem. Pretty bad when my 7 year old daughter noticed how rude the lady is Read more
Have ordered pizza from there over 20 times since they opened. That sample size is large enough to say definitively the Casey?s... is great. The few times there have been an issue, store staff has made it right. I?ve only ever gotten pizza from there, so Ican?t review anything else really. Read more
Clean place, friendly staff
Haven't been in yet, but I'm glad they're here, I haven't seen the gas prices stay the same for so many days in a row for 20... years!???????? Finally tried the pizza, wasnt expecting much diff from other area pizza HOWEVER, it was VERY GOOD!!!????????. Ido like more garlic in the sauce, but even with that it was in my top 3. WELL DONE CASEY! Read more
Being from the Midwest where there is a Casey?s store around every corner, I was so excited to see them make their way to Ohio. ... Pizza is amazing, fresh ingredients, fast, and delicious! Homemade donuts and other goodies are also very good! Read more
Casey's has been one amazing surprise after another since my girlfriend and I learned about them. Their baked goods are... delicious and fairly priced--and still fresh near closing time--and the regular menu of cooked food is much the same. Leaguesbeyond similar convenience stores like Speedway. Staff is also incredibly friendly, nice to talk to and helpful. Going to becoming here again and again. Read more
Stopped in to grab a slice of pizza, I got home & I realized I should?ve gotten the whole thing. It was amazing, so delicious.