Reviews for Jolly Roger's Pizzeria in New London, WI
Great people and good food. You have to try their stuffed pizza it is unbelievable
We had one of the best pizzas we'd ever had in the past. We were there Monday afternoon and our Young girl raitress was great
Pizza is good and customer service has been mediocre everytime I have gone. One specific time a staff member gave us a very... poor attitude and acted impatient when we were asking about their nutrition facts for our diabetic friend. They were not busywhen we came in so I don't understand the problem. Other times their waitstaff have just have acted very short with some oftheir customers. The restaurant itself is clean and appears to be well kept, and they have very nice decorations. Read more
I had the 10 inch personal size pizza for 12 bucks. It had sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black and green... olives, and lots of parmesan all on the regular crust. I washed it down with a Sprecher root beer. My wife ordered a sausage andpepperoni on regular crust, and my son had chicken tenders. Honestly, two of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. Crust wascooked perfectly, and the sauce complimented the toppings exquisitely. I even snuck a bite of a chicken tender and was pleasedat how good even that tasted. We'll definitely be back! Read more
First time ordering my husband got the Italian beef and really liked it I got the Chicken Parm I asked for it to be deep... fried with mozzarella and it came broiled and so tough and the lettuce was wilted because they put it on a hot sandwich DUH?!!!Never again I'll just stick to their pizza Read more
The pizza is cheap, the taste is amazing. Everything on the menu is amazing. If I have 1 complaint, it would be I would like to... place my order online. That is all. Everything else is perfect. Read more
We really enjoy their frozen pizzas and decided to try their fresh made. We loved it! The pizza was fantastic. Light and crunchy... thin crust, but not tough. The sandwiches were tasty and dessert was good. Very affordable and a nice atmosphere. Read more
Food was good. Waitress was great. Atmosphere was pleasant. Would definitely eat here again.