Reviews for Seafood Sally's in New Orleans, LA
This place was quite simply one of the better dining experiences I’ve had in awhile. From the ambiance and color scheme to the... delightful staff, it was enjoyable just getting to our table. The guy brought our oysters (ballers dozen) and explained eachone. They were delectable. The fried green tomatoes with assorted greens salad were the best maybe I can remember. The poboy hadflaky Bahn mi bread with homemade pickles and perfectly fried oysters. But the triumph of the experience was the sweet & savorycornbread. As a side the ice tea was somehow better and more refreshing than common ice tea, I forgot to ask exactly what theleaf was. In addition to all of this the servers all had great senses of humor and timing. Especially Melvin who brought theoysters and said he was our “mother shucker”. Would recommend to anyone. Read more
Came in during their oyster happy hour. Unfortunately we weren’t told that there was a difference in price between the... different oysters they served, and had to pay full price on 2 dozen oysters because they weren’t part of the promotion. $64 isa lot more then $24. Would have appreciated if our server told us beforehand, knowing we were there for happy hour pricing. Weeven asked while ordering to make sure, and they assured us the oysters would be priced at happy hour. All good tho, didn’tmake a big deal, paid the bill and still tipped well. Just wish they would’ve worked with us on the price. Review would behigher if not for all that. Food and drinks were good nonetheless. Not tryna put anyone on blast so I cropped out the serversname. Read more
Oysters 10/10 - a dozen for $28 Corn breaded onion rings -AMAZING & gluten free paired w the perfect sauce Caesar salad was... ok, leaves wilted from the catfish we added to it- should have been on the side 4/10 Lemongrass slaw wasn’t creamy like aslaw & no actual lemongrass flavor. Tasted like straight vinegar 4/10 Our order was almost $100 Seems like the sides voverpriced When we come back it’ll be for the oysters & onion rings exclusively Read more
There aren’t enough words. It’s SO GOOD I’ve been here twice in less than 36 hrs. Amazing ???? Great Roasted Garlic Shrimp... / Crawfish Etouffee / LET’S TALK ABOUT THE CORNBREAD ???????? I am addicted! Today we had the Boil Pot ???? I have absolutelynothing to complain about! Home run!!! I must add the place is beautiful and the staff is top notch. They even get 2% of ur billfor mental health ?? We were 4 ppl ate with $100 Read more
I’ve dined here approximately twice a month for the last several months. Inside and outside, different servers, and different... orders. I’m so pleased that Seafood Sally’s has established itself on Oak street. The oyster happy hour is clutch. Thecrawfish chili butter is HOT and delicious. I’ve had the shrimp bahn mi, fish poboy, boils, and a sheepshead catch of the day(wow!). I love that they have a non-alcoholic beers and mocktails - would love to see more New Orleans establishments followsuit. The outdoor patio is enclosed and the seating is spacious so my friends with kids love coming here so the little ones canroam a bit without disturbing others. Today I sat on the porch and the Jasmine smelled so sweet. Read more
Walked here while staying locally. Tried the Crawfish Etouffee, Oysters on the half shell and Abita beer which was... local. -Food was very good but portions were not large. So if there is a knock it is that you aren't going to leave stuffed ifthat is what you are going for. Example- the hush puppy appetizer was 2 hush puppies. -Indoor and out door seating and out doorseems to be dog friendly. -Beer that I ordered was canned but had hoped for on tap as it was a local brew. -Etouffee wasflavorful but not particularly spicy the crawfish was plentiful and all but a set of head and tails was already peeled andde-veined tail meat. -Oysters on the half shell tasted fresh and came with the usual crackers, cocktail, horseradish and vinegaroptions. Overall the venue was suitable for casual dining, food was enjoyable, and prices were moderate. I'd eat here again. Read more
Awesome dining experience! The Turkey necks were legit. As someone who hadnt had them before, were very delicious. The oysters... were huge and reasonably priced. The fried pickles were prime. Next time I think I'd go with a sandwich or platter over the boilas it was a bit on the spicy side for me. Will eat again. Read more
This place was by far the best restaurant I ate at during my stay in NOLA. The food was so. freaking. amazing. We had the fried... turkey necks, honey butter cornbread, flame broiled shrimp, bbq blue crab and a slice of key lime pie. I can’t even pick onebecause it was all so good. The staff was very friendly too and the place had a great atmosphere. I felt like I was havingdinner at grandmas house. Can’t wait to come back to Seafood Sally’s! Read more