Reviews for Gourmet Pizza in New Paltz, NY
Gourmet is amazing. My boyfriend and I DREAM about their Chicken, Bacon, Ranch pizza? and he?s lactose intolerant!! Tried a CBR... from another local place one night when Gourmet was closed and it was horrible. Immediately vowed to only buy Gourmet?s pizza inNew Paltz, especially CBR. Seriously, go here. Eat their pizza. Try the best chicken, bacon, ranch pizza I?ve ever laid my tastebuds on. Read more
If I could give this place more stars I would, love the pizza and the guys who make it, The register girls are also super sweet,... a great place to hit up after the bars! Read more
The meatball parm sub was awesome! Great flavor, big portion and fairly priced. Will definitely order it again ??????????
Grandma pizza was not similar to the grandma pizza I'm familiar with. It was not terrible but I should have just stuck with a... regular pie. The wings were just okay. The caesar salad was terrible -- just lettuce and sub-par dressing. Read more
I used to eat here all the time before covid. This place is a staple to my college experience. However, quality has been really... trash as of recently especially when they leave this blonde girl and boy in charge. The pizza dough was raw when I got home, andso were the garlic knots. My friends tried the wings and the chicken tasted like a butcher shop which means the chicken wasprobably extremely old. I?m honestly so disgusted and disappointed. Some of us threw up the next morning no doubt because of theactually bad food we consumed. If you wanna keep your organs intact, I?d say to go to Rinos Pizza. Ps. I also called to letthem know items were missing and that the food was raw, and they approached me with a lot of attitude while telling me to callTuesday for the owner. Y?all think y?all slick but with this type of quality and customer service... idk man. This place isn?twhat it used to be. Someone call Gordon Ramsay Read more
By far the worst pizza I?ve ever had in my life. Extremely low quality cheese (rubbery and weird taste) and virtually no sauce... on the pizza. I see why they charge an extra $0.75 for marinara (never saw a pizza place charge for this)... there?s probably somany people asking for extra because they put none on the pie. Dominos definitely makes better pizza than this place... verydisappointed because this used to be one of my favorite pizza places in town. Read more
Me and my girlfriend are from Buffalo Ny and this place has been awesome. We have ordered pizza's 2 different time's and each... pizza was cooked perfectly. We stopped in around midnight on our visits. The employees are nice and easy to talk to. Keep up thegreat work everyone. Read more
Don?t support a place where workers standby and not help an innocent customer being hate crimed!! I witnessed a customer minding... her business waiting in line where two people were causing a disturbance and assaulting the customer meanwhile the employeesstood by and did nothing. If you own a place and someone is causing a disturbance u do something not be a bystander. Theirsilence spoke louder than anything in the restaurant. They don?t care about their customers. It?s not worth their food or money. Read more