Reviews for Maggie Mae's in New Paltz, NY
We were originally planning on going to the Gastropub on the same property but unfortunately, they were booked for the night.... They told us about this place which was right next door. Since we were passing by and we?re starving, we decided to give it atry. The place is pretty nice with nice views. There was only one table there which was a bit concerning. Our waitress was verynice and the food came fast. Everything was surprisingly good! The clam chowder was made from scratch. The appetizers werereally big and could totally pass for full meals. Overall great experience!!!! Read more
Maggie Mae's always is a great place to go for lunch or dinner. I've had a great breakfast there as well! The bar is great too.... They can pour a perfect Guinness or a tasty satisfying gin and tonic (the "Effing" is the best!). Sometimes there's live music???? Read more
Super friendly and accommodating with our dogs! Loved the fish and chips. We sat outside on the terrace looking over the... beautiful golf course with the mountains in the background. We'll definitely be back. Read more
Such a lovely restaurant. We celebrated my daughters birthday here and couldn?t have asked for a better experience. The staff... was extremely kind and attentive. Food was delicious and service was excellent. Wonderful restaurant with a fabulous view too! Read more
Delicious food... awesome views... and even nicer service! We met Gavin the owner and had a lovely waiter. We can't wait to come... back! It is our new favorite spot for whenever we come back to the gunks. It's amazing having nice service!! Thanks againGavin! Had the clam chowder and house salad with shrimp and it was delightful! Everyone enjoyed their meals! Read more
First you'll love the view then you'll learn that the service is friendly and accommodating then you'll have the food that is so... good completely matching the service and the view! We will definitely comeback here next time we're in New paltz! The classicchowder is a must try! Read more
Pleasantly busy, with cheerful and engaged staff. Well organized and efficient, with minimal time lost to waiting. Beverage... order was prompt to arrive, and no feeling of being rushed to order our meal. The food was good and to our liking. Not fancy,nor did we expect it to be. Good fare. Good service. Good price for us. Thank you for a great experience. Read more
We were just passing through and saw that this place had good reviews so we decided to stop. So glad we did - we had such a... great dinner! It was set a bit back from the parking lot but when we got inside we were greeted by Pete who could not have beenmore kind or welcoming. The food was delicious (chicken nachos, ceasar salad, French dip)! If we were locals we would absolutelybe back, but I'm so glad we found this place - would absolutely recommend! Read more