Reviews for East of Chicago Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH

Love their buffet and it's really affordable for a family on a budget. Never had a bad experience here and employees are... stellar! Read more

Good fresh food on their lunch buffet, located on the Southside of new phila Ohio. Kind of hidden but worth it.

Food is good. I like the buffet but when I go and it's 30 minutes past the start time, I sit and wait 10 minutes for the first... pizza. The salad bar isn't even set up yet. If you are a patient person and in no rush to eat I highly recommend the buffet. Ifyou need to eat in 30 minutes or less, order take out. The cups are so small (free refills) I need about 10 refills per visit. Iunderstand paper cups but this is ridiculous. Update: upon last visit they got bigger cups. Read more

Sense they've moved buildings they have improved so much! Food is always good.

Ordered my food. 45 minutes later I get the wrong pizzas. I then call back. They say that they are sending my new pizzas. 2... hours later still no pizzas. 10:20 at night now. Read more

We love this place! The staff is always nice and they do their best to keep up on the buffet even when they're short staffed and... super busy! Read more

Service was great we went there a half an hour before the buffet closed and they were still making fresh food for it

Ordered pizza & there was hardly any sauce on it. Very dry! Cheese was all brown on top and went you bit pizza the whole topping... came off in one bite. Ordered garlic cheese bread and it had no flavor to it. Also, the dipping sauce was ice cold, right out offridge! Found a dark hair on my pizza which was gross! And you need to change prices on your site! I would have came back toyour store for a return but we were up at the Hospital and waiting on news for a family member. Wont be buying anything at yourplace again!! Read more