Reviews for Joey's New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant in New Port Richey, FL

This was our first time eating here, we were going to go to the Port Richey Olive Garden However we are so disappointed with the... terrible Service at the Olive Garden that we decided to try This pizza place. I am happy that we tried Joey’s Pizza on 19 inNew Port Richey. The pizza was Delicious and the Rest of the food was really good. I will definitely go back! See you soon. Read more

So this is how our Italian subs came out today ????, exact same sandwich. Look at the difference. ??? At least the ones with the... messed up tomatoes, didn't have a long hair in it ????, like the other one did gross ???? I won't be back Read more

Very good pizza plus all the regular Italian favourites. Service was awesome. Waitress was really patient and right on point... with drink refills. Very friendly. We had a 10 year old with us, and he was very happy with his extra cheese pizza we had acouple of heroes, not bad. For 5 of us, bill was $67 total, including tax. Really good Caesar salad. Read more

We have been dining at this location for at least a couple years now. At first, it was great! Lately, the quality of the food... has definitely gone down. The last few times I ordered lasagna or baked ziti, it was cold in the middle. Tonight it happenedagain. We didn’t bother telling the waitress this time and instead just took our food to go and reheated it. When we got thebill, we also noticed that they are now charging 3.5% for paying with a credit/debit card. They don’t warn you about thisprior to ordering or bringing the bill. Menu prices have also increased, but due to inflation, that was expected. For the priceand extra charges, this place just isn’t worth it anymore. I can’t believe I’m going to say this, but Olive Garden wouldhave been better quality and less expensive tonight. Read more

Sat eve, no wait. We each had a small salad. Shared the mushroom app and the ravioli app. We brought leftovers home...... Absolutely delish!! Blackberry sangria was super fresh-fruity!! Read more

Ordered slices of pizza - took forever. Sersly, how long does it take to slap slices of pizza on a couple plates? Get the slices... and none of the cheese slices look the same. Mine is not edible at all. I can’t even hold it up to put in my mouth without itgoing limp and falling to my plate. I will not be eating here again. I’m Italian, I know my pizza. This is not good pizza. Read more

I read multiple reviews before ordering so I will try to address my experience from previous reviews. I called in my order for... the first time and the girl on the phone was nice and, just like any place, let me know my total before my pizza came. I ordereda large supreme pizza and wings. The pizza came loaded with delicious toppings and was PERFECTLY cooked. The wings were plumpand the sauce was on point. They told me it would be here within an hour (I ordered on a Saturday night about 9pm) and it washere on or before that time. The delivery driver was cool and I tipped him well because I feel I am a little to the edge oftheir delivery area (Also, if you tip well in a restaurant, tip your driver well. They actually PAY to get your food to you).Overall, I am fully satisfied with this order. I hate to see negative reviews but I understand stuff happens. as a first timecustomer I will call back. Some pretty damn good stuff. Read more

Ordered an extra cheese, pepperoni and sausage pizza online. It arrived pretty quickly and delivered w care. The bread was... perfectly crispy and they didn't hold back on the toppings. Price was great for the quality of food. Definitely will be orderingagain! ???? Read more