Reviews for Joey's New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant in New Port Richey, FL

The staff seemed hard working especially the young lady that greeted and waited on us. The menu had all you could ask for and... more as far as Italian restaurants go. They even had some things I usually don't see like Vodka sauce pasta. The restaurantitself is quite small inside and my family had only ordered takeout before so I wasn't expecting much to be honest but I noticedthey try their best to be greater than they appear. I was happily eager to see what I ordered, the fettuccine Alfredo. It wasgreat. Portions are quite generous too haha. Prices are reasonable especially the sandwiches or subs for lunch. Read more

We stopped in to have dinner on Wednesday at 8:10 pm on 10/4/2022. The young girl making pizza boxes noticed us as soon as we... walked in and asked us if we were picking up an order to go. We said no, we were dining in.I asked if it was alright. Shewalked to the desk to look at something and she said um let me check, I guess so. Then she said just so you know we close in 40minutes. I said, ok and she said, sit wherever you'd like. We decided to leave because we didn't feel welcome and that we weredining to close to closing time even though it was 50 minutes before closing time. Read more

Best pasta I've ever eaten. We were at the brewery and placed a to go order and they brought it TO US next door. Very friendly... and good value. Read more

Cute Italian place in a Publix strip mall. Walked in and was seated immediately. I decided to sit outside bc it was a nice day... and the outside seats are comfortable. Server was very efficient and attentive. Food was quick and a great price for lunch.Under $9 for special including eggplant Parm hoagie, salad and drink. The salad was fresh and large portion. The hoagie was justok, which is why the 4 star. The cheese on top was not fully melted in places and the sauce didn't have much flavor. The serverdidn't offer any condiments but I was in a hurry and didn't really think about adding flavor to improve the taste. Perfect placefor a quick and casual lunch. Read more

Mom and I decided to try out this new place her friends recommended. For me the soup had something added to it which didn't... fancy me some type of spice but my lasagna was very good. Mom got a caesar salad along with chicken parmesan with spaghetti verygenerous portions. This is a place where you can make two or three meals out of what they give you Read more

Wrote a review for NPR location as well. I love the 2 slices at lunch and they hit the mark. Other than that I would never go... back to eat here. First and foremost the seating is awkward at best. And please do not sit in the last row where you can seeinto the kitchen. I watched these guys reach into the drawer that has the pasta in it and they had no gloves on. And the lasttime we ate there the garlic knots (after we ate one) we noticed were moldy. The chef came out and apologized a 100 times buthey moldy food is moldy food now matter how small it was. I am sad because this place is close and does have good Alfredo sauce. Read more

Before I submit online reviews I always CALL and to talk to the manager politely to let them know there was an issue with my... order so they have a chance to rectify the situation. We order from here 2-3x a month, it's close to home and we likesupporting local businesses. The past 3 times that they've messed up our order I call, and they issue a credit for our nextorder. Apparently this system doesn't exist anymore. We've had pizzas very undercooked and sopping wet, missing items, etc.Quality is very spotty, but when it's good it's great. Thought the issues were growing pains when they first opened, but it'sbeen what, 2 years now? Our order today was a pepperoni pizza and a Greek salad, no olives. Drive home we have a cheese pizzaand Greek salad with black olives. Not such a big deal on the olives, but the pizza, no bueno. Call the place and they saythey'll remake the pizza if we return it now and wait an additional 30-40 mins. Sorry, kids are starving and smelling pizzaalready. They offer to refund the $1 topping and want all our info over the phone. This is not how you grow you're customerbase. Just remake the pizza you messed up on, or give a credit. Not ordering from here again, not worth the hassle andconsistent messed up orders for basic food items. Read more

First time dining here and this place is absolutely awesome!!! The la nonna pizza was to die for and way more food than 2 humans... can eat. The ambiance was great and the service was exceptional! The prices are amazing! I expected a small personal pizza forthe $15, and as you can see not even close. It was probably 18 inches by 12. It was loaded with cheese!! Top it off with lemoncake with mascarpone frosting. Can you say hello food coma.... yum. Read more