Reviews for Flagler Avenue Pizza Company in New Smyrna Beach, FL

Don't sleep on this pizza shop for either a quick slice or convenient delivery. Highly recommend the Grandmother slice.... Unbelievably delicious with a perfect balance on garlic and red sauce and love. The prices are easy on the budget as well. Read more

A nice pizza place by Flagler beach. Good sized pizzas with reasonable prices. Liked the thin and crispy pizza. Pretty extensive... menu and they have lots of topping options. There is some seating inside, and only one bench seating outside. Friendly staff andgood customer service. Pizza was tasty. Read more

Hands down the best in New Smyrna. We love the Caprese pizza. The Calamari pizza is amazing too! Honestly, we haven?t tried... anything we haven?t enjoyed. The crust is delicious and the sauce is savory! Read more

Was darn good, ordered 2 large pizzas could have gotten away with 1 for 5 people.

The pizza is good and it doesn't take long to get a pie made, but there isn't anything special about the place. Are you staying... at the beach and want a pizza night? This place will certainly fit the need. The convenient location makes this my choice forpizza on the beach. Read more

Awesome pizza! We just popped in for a slice at lunch, and we're so impressed that we had them deliver 3 large pizzas home for... dinner! Brilliant, friendly dine in atmosphere and excellent delivery service. Read more

Horribly soggy Gluten Free pizza. The regular pizza looked good and my family loved it, but their Gluten free was definitely not... cooked well and droopy and way too moist! We ordered one cheese GF and one with veggies; both were floppy and just gross. I doNOT recommend their GF. So sad- for the price of pizza it was very underwhelming! Read more

Pictured is large traditional pizza with pepperoni and mushroom. The pizza was hot, fresh and had great flavor; with thin crust... and was quite large! We got bruschetta which had good flavor but got a bit soggy on the delivery. We also got ceasar salad inwhich the dressing was good but the cheese had mold and took away from our overall rating. If we had just ordered pizza therating would have been much higher because the pizza was excellent ???? Read more