Reviews for Casey's in New Ulm, MN
I have called two days in a row to order a pizza. First day I was too late. Today the kitchen closed over 45 minutes earlier... than they said it would last night. I?m 8 months preggo n been craving pizza from Casey?s for days but apparently they don?tneed to keep consistent hours. They get to close whenever they feel like it. Wish my job was like that! Read more
Nice c-store for quick purchases. In & out, this place is rarely crowded.
normally I like Casey's pizza. I especially like the taco pizza (I'll pick the taco over any other taco pizza in town,... depending on my mood) with plentiful tomato and lettuce. But this time it was actually terrible--and and for me to take thetime to make a bad review, it's takes beyond the normal "it's ok, I guess" rating. I want their pizza to be good, so pleasetake this as constructive. The sauce and cheese tasted off, the crust was ok, the cheese/tomato/topping were way under thenormal amount. It just didn't taste good. Also, one of the cooks and the cashier were not wearing face masks...here inMinnesota it is the law. THis was at 7:07 pm July 26, 2020. Read more
We ordered the Family meal deal which was a large 1 topping pizza, a 2 liter bottle of pop, bread sticks and dessert. I ordered... online and my husband picked it up. We got the wrong pizza, he had to ask for the pop, no dessert and burnt bread sticks. Wecalled the store and all they said was thanks, we learn from our mistakes! I contacted the company and they won't evenrespond! Caseys has lost a customer. Read more
Used to be best pizza around used to order at least2x a week I never order it anymore because it's not the same it's just like... Dominos now and sucks crust is different and not very much toppings just disapointing Read more
2nd best gas station in town. Kwik Trip is overall better, But no shame stopping here if you need something before leaving town.
Friendly small town atmosphere! Love the hospitality. None of the Casey's I stop at ever have the monthly featured pizza by the... slice. (Gaylord, New Ulm, Fairfax, Madelia) Read more
Used to be good pizza but last few times it was awful. My family waits months & then reorders to see if they've improved. ... NOPE-DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY. My husband used to make pizza there so he called to request the dough be rolled fresh. It was not.Literally 1 to 2 pepperonis per slice. Cheese sloppy and all over the crust. Pretty sure a young child without cookng experiencecould do better. Casey's will get NO more chances to change our mind. GARBAGE! Read more