Reviews for La casa de la Empanada Colombiana in New Windsor, NY

My family and I just made a quick stop. We had a few chicken and beef empanadas, and also an order of tostones. Everything was... made to order, and really fresh and delicious. What a great find! Read more

This hidden gem or hole in the wall restaurant provides the most delectable Latino food in NY. The rice & beans and chicharon... delicious, also the empanadas. They are original like our grandparents made them. Not with the modern dough and process foodsbut with true corn and vegetables. You need to go to this place. It is esthetically clean and the family run mom and pops shopwill make you so welcomed. Read more

Giving the food 5 stars but I have to say the place is dirty, covered in dust and cobb webbs. Paint is dirty, window dirty,... tables were sticky, back of seat covers were filthy. It doesnt take money for fresh paint and some cleaner. I would suggest tospent a couple bucks to freshen up the waiting area. It is a turn off to see delicious food being made in a dirty place. Goodfood and nice people. Read more

New Windsor Hidden GEM - First-time Customer - Now I'm a raving fan! You've never had Empanadas like these. Highly recommend the... veg and cheese! Order ahead because it does take a bit of time but that's because they are MADE FRESH! What more could you askfor! Read more

Nice and cozy spot for empanadas near Storm King. Dropped by on a hungry Saturday afternoon after visiting Storm King which is... just a few minutes away. They have a simple and short menu and we got a bunch of empanadas - veg, chicken, and beef - amongstus. After a long wait - they apparently make them from scratch - we quickly got to work when we got the order. Golden coloredwith a thick, doughy outer shell, the empanadas were hot and tasty and came with a creamy white sauce which was quitegood. With a visit if you're in the area but go brace yourself for a longish wait. Read more

So I bought these on the go. Ran in, placed an order and 15 min later it was ready. Overall, very pleased with the flavor though... it was a little salty...plus the empanadas I ordered were pretty nicely stuffed! However through the delectable bites... ididn't see any chopped onions, peppers, cilantro or anything else to give it that visual flavor pop ????. No salsa on the sideeither... Was I supposed to ask for it? IDK.... but I'll come back and hopefully they dump a cup of scallions in my to- go boxbecause they read this too! Read more

Amazing food , Service was Great !! I Love My New Colombian Family !! I had the Empanadas Chicken and Shrimp Cooked to... Perfection! I will be back soon I can’t wait to experience this Food Again . Read more

OMG! The best empanadas and arepas around! Totally authentic. The staff is wonderful and friendly. I can't stop going and the... prices are great! ?????????? The juices are just as good!! I hope they are around for a long time! Read more