Reviews for Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria in New Windsor, NY

The food tonight was absolutely delicious ! Butternut squash raviolis, sausage and peppers on pasta, fish and chips and chicken... marsala. The menu seems to be endless and these culinary delights brought together a fun night of dining followed by freshcoffee and scrumptious deserts. Thank You to the Team at Mamma Mia\'s. Stop by and see for yourself ! Read more

This place is really good. The staff was nice, and the food was great. The first time I went with my dad, the waitress was... really the sweetest you have ever met! When we left, the waitress told us to come back again. 10/10 Read more

Today was the first day that I entered this cute little establishment in New Windsor. The beautiful lady that greeted me and... talked to me about her restaurant. I ordered the chicken Alfredo with a salad. She gave me a slice of pepperoni pizza and itreminded me of my Brooklyn pizza. This was an amazing slice. Best pizza in New Windsor I will definitely recommend this place toeveryone. Amazing food Read more

This place is great in every way! The food was delicious and you get a lot, the service, the prices, and it\'s so cute! We... loved it, and we are so happy they are in our neighborhood.\n\nThis is an update to my original review. We’ve been severaltimes since and still love the food, but when we went last night there was loud music and it was the kind of music you wouldexpect in loud nightclub kind of place — not in a cute little cozy cafe. We will only go for lunch now and hope it’s stilla quiet relaxing atmosphere then. Read more

Staff is really nice. Pizza is good. Chicken bacon ranch is my new favorite! Philly cheesesteaks were a hit with the husband. ... Will go back Read more

1st time visit. Bought a couple subs (Turkey, American combo) here and a wrap(chippy chicado) for takeout. Everything was great... and they don\'t use cheap deli meats like other places. Definitely will return. Read more

Great BREAKFAST! Who woulda thought an Italian restaurant would serve such great breakfast? Coffee is very good, and served in... large mug. Omelets are delicious...but the home fries are the best EVER! They are deep fried, crispy, and not greasy. Linksausage was spicy and cooked to crunch just a little.\n\nGenerous portions.\n\nThis place is clean and bright. We MUST try lunchand dinner here. Read more

They cook everything, as in they make pizza while also reserving the ability to make a hamburger in this Italian style... restaurant. The food they use to prepare the meals must be quality because it tastes good and the way they prepare the foodmakes you want to come back! Also, the interior of the restaurant gives you a warm and cozy feeling. Read more