Reviews for Primo's Pizza in New Windsor, NY
We tried Primo's last time we were in the area and reprised it again last week. It was selected because it was close to our... hotel. They did not disappoint! We got pizza,a salad and split a cannoli. The salad was ultra fresh. And the pizza? We got thetraditional this crust (they also have Sicilian) with pepperoni and roasted red peppers. Perfect blend of tasty crust, flavorfulsauce and yummy toppings. They also have a full menu of Italian favorites. Check this place out!! Read more
Omg!!! The BEST pizza I've had in several decades???????????? Always fresh and cheesey.????
If you want a napkin-wasting, greasy, drippy, absolutely DELICIOUS NYC-style pie, you go to Primo's. This is the stuff tourists... go to New York to sample and it's right here in our own back yard. The price can feel steep due to inflation, but what businessisn't raising prices at the moment? HIGHLY recommend. But don't come here if you're looking for something healthy ???????? Read more
So I've been a New Windsor/Newburgh native since I was born and I can say this is the best pizza in the area. I've tried the big... named chains and the mass amount of local spots that this area is almost over flooded with, but this is the best one and I wishI knew about them much sooner. I was introduced to them by a close friend who lives near them, as I assume is the case for mostpeople who order pizza in their area. However, I recommend giving them a try even if it's a little out of the way. I promise youwon't be disappointed. Read more
Wings are garbage.. poured the entire bottle of mild sauce in the container for the wings which caused my car seat to get... stained. Horrible service Read more
The best part of the meal was the incredibly sweet waitress. The pizza was really good and what was even better was the... eggplant roll. The eggplant was sliced think and fried to perfection! Absolutely a great little restaurant and they are openlate. The servings are nice and large. Read more
Best veal parmigiana, real thick juicy veal, not pounded. Great pizza. Owner and staff friendly and courteous. Give it a try and... you'll be back for more. Read more
Looking for a quick slice? This is the spot. Huge slices, good prices and delicious flavor. Give them a try!