Reviews for Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor in New Windsor, NY

I eat there a lot. Best crust. Always good. Customer for life

My rating or opinion of this pizzeria use to be between good or fair..But after my mother had a leftover slice of mushroom today... she actually found a few tiny gravel or sand rocks inside!!! Lack of sanitation totally sooo don't bother buying pizza there atall....Terrible Read more

This place was great when it was Sal's pizza. Sal & his wife ran the place it was great they where very lovely people. But sadly... as time goes on so does the quality the Redesign And the name change to tosco's. The quality the passion the care Sal built inthat location was gone and so was it soul. The food at times is like freezer burned the pizza quality is meh. There used to besoul. Now there's just a void in its stead. Long live Sal's tosco's is far from what it meant to be a place with greatmemories.To being just another sub par pizza joint around the Newburgh/NewWindsor area. Read more

We asked for a cup of their marinara sauce before we ordered There sauce is not sweet thank god! I find a lot of pizza places... make their sauce sweet like candy. I don?t know why . It?s Small place but there pizza is excellent. Read more

Great subs! I go here routinely, or get subs delivered. Pizza slices look good too, although I have only had them twice. One was... great, one was okay. Read more

QUALITY pizzeria! CLEAN environment,courteous staff. Fresh food, large portions,excellent prices. Was impressed that even their... side salad was excellent. Something I would put together for my own family. Dark greens,cherry tomatoes, cucumber, roasted redpeppers and onions. They care about quality and excellent customer service. Read more

Good food & friendly staff. Def would come back if in the area... came here after visiting Storm King Art Center. Order 2 rolls,... one chicken parmigiana and one steak and cheese and both were delicious and large. Read more

We just moved here from Rochester, NY and we've been trying to find a good pizza place! Well, we found it! I took my daughter... here for lunch yesterday and not only was the food amazing, but the customer service was awesome and the owner was superfriendly. They even offered to cut up the pizza for my daughter. It was so good I had to have my husband try it so here we areordering one day later. Again, the best customer service over the phone, especially considering it's a Saturday night. The girlon the phone was patient and very nice. I won't be ordering from anywhere else! We are so happy we found a great place thatvalues its customers and has great and hard working employees! Also a super nice dining area! Read more