Reviews for 42nd Street Pizza in New York, NY
It's a nice looking restaurant. The food is decent. The customer service sucks. It's my 2nd time visiting this establishment... post pandemic. The regular pizza is my favorite. The latino guy who serves it, isn't. He was very rude to me. He messed up myorder and then got mad when I asked him to correct it. He acted as if he didn't want to put another pizza in the oven. Heinsisted I only said I wanted 1 slice when I wanted 3. Strange. Read more
Sweet Diner like vibe. I ordered their burger with spinach and mozzarella cheese...Deliciousness. My food remained fresh and... Hot for about 7-10 mins of waiting before eating. Servers and management was professional and greeted me. Prices arereasonable too. I will go back and try something different. Read more
Had a GREAT lunch here last week. We had no plans on eating in this area but needed something quick. This place was perfect. The... pizza was exceptional, the burgers were tasty, and the staff was super friendly and helpful. The area was surprisingly empty andwe were the only customers at that time. I'm not sure why that was the case...this place is a hidden gem. Read more
Great family owned diner in a great part of Manhattan. Food was great and service was great. My favorite part was noticing that... this diner is very family oriented. Would come back whenever I’m around the area. Read more
On this dark street this well lit family store offers good quality hot food made with fresh produce that you can taste. The... bathroom is clean an well lit as well, family friendly staff, lots of foot traffic however fast service. One of kind atmospherefor a low price. Read more
This place is a disgrace to Greek and Italian food, especially for NY style food. Service was good, but what restaurant have you... ever seen where they don't have cups and you have to buy $2 water bottles? For that high prices, you would expect good food. Read more
The pizza was good, but they overcharged us by $8. 2 slices of pizza, a coke and milkshake cost us $25 when it should have been... $17. No amount of sales tax or tip should cover that. AVOID AT ALL COSTS Read more
Really nice combo of greek and italian food and very cozy and homey atmosphere.