Reviews for Atlantic Grill in New York, NY

We celebrated my girlfriend's birthday recently at the Atlantic Grill. The food, service, and atmosphere were amazing. I highly... recommend anyone interested in fine dining to visit the Atlantic Grill. Read more

Cocktails are the best thing, going at this place. Food Bland. From the caesar salad, to the soup, to the sushi, to the curry... all bland. This was the worst Caesar salad, I ever had and how do you mess that up!? However the service is amazing and againthe cocktails are delicious and Pack-a-Punch. Read more

I love this place. Service is top notch. Very attentive staff. Drinks are really good. Only reason why I don’t give it 5 is... because 2nd time I come and my friend’s Paella ???? smelled kind of funny. I’ve had paella before I know what it taste andsmells like most of the time. Other wise their fish is really good. I had salmon and steak other times, I don’t have anycomplaints. Would I go there again? Yes certainly, it’s a very nice place to have dinner, a couple of drinks and have a goodtime. -Thank you to the staff for making this a good experience! :) Read more

Shockingly tasteless, small, dried out scallops. Would have had no taste without the 2 sauces served. At $49 a portion, they... should have been much larger, juicier, and more flavorful. Total rip-off. Mediocre service. Had to ask for things 3 or 4times before they showed up, like a clean fork. We wanted to order dessert, but after 10+ minutes of waiting for the dessertmenu, we ran out of time as we had opera tickets. Read more

What an amazing surprise!!! I never cared for the west side Atlantic Grill, much preferring the one on the east side. Both are... now closed, but the Atlantic Grill on the west side scaled itself down to a gracious, inviting space with wonderful seating andimpeccable service. The menu is substantially different with the only familiar item being the seafood tower. Everything wesampled was inventive and perfectly prepared. Maybe the most outstanding difference was the service. This is a place you willwant to return to. I believe they should give themselves a fresh name. As I was leaving the restaurant I stopped to talked topeople who were reading the menu. They also remembered the old Atlantic Grill and were dubious about the reopening. I assuredthem that they should give the new place a try. Read more

Quality ingredients and good tastes. Service was top notch.

Great ambience. Beautifu presentation. Fresh and delicious seafood and amazing service too. Really enjoying everything from... our appetizers( snapper sashimi, octopus, Greek salad..) to desserts(lychee cheesecake, brownie) and looking forward to comingback soon to try other foods on the menu! Oh and the bar looks amazing !! Nice to have a beautiful bar in the neighborhood tograb drinks and small bites !! ???? Read more

Average food, the presentation and service were great, but the food was just meh. For the heavy price tag, just really wasn’t... flavorful enough for me. For appetizers we ordered the calamari, which was delicious. This was probably the standout of themeal, everything else was just okay. Got the dragon roll and also the spicy California roll, each were average tasting. Thisplace clearly isn’t a sushi destination. For the entrees, our group ordered the steamed mussels/clams which weren’t asfresh as they looked. The ravioli, again, subpar. I had the paella which was decent, and the shrimp curry which wasalright. Again, nothing wrong with this place. Service was fine. Food was alright. Probably wouldn’t recommend this to anyonethough. Read more