Reviews for Black Tap in New York, NY
These milkshakes are out of control. Visiting New York City for one day only and after seeing the pictures I had to make a stop.... This is not a place for the feint of heart or small of stomach. A full milkshake with a sprinkle frosting rim topped with anentire slice of funfetti cake, covered in sprinkles, topped with whipped cream, then topped with a cherry. This bazillioncalorie treat wasn't easy to finish, and the fact that I pushed myself through to the very end is a testament to just howdeliciously perfect every single bite was. If you're near Central Park South and you've got a major sweet tooth or a bad sugarcraving you can bet black tap will have just the thing to wet your whistle. Read more
Food was absolutely delicious!! I opted for the Back Tap Burger salad & my boyfriend got the all American burger. It was... genuinely so tasty. The caramelised onions were just devine. It cost about $50 for two meals and 1 diet coke, including tax anda 20% tip. The service was also amazing, the waitress was so sweet and attentive. The decor is also very funky. Read more
The wait is not worth the food at all. I was quite excited about their extravagant milkshakes, but they did not live up to my... expectations whatsoever. We ordered three different ones and all of the milkshake bases were flavorless. The cake on top of minewas also flavorless. The service is slow and the ambiance is horrible. The only decent thing was the burger, but you can getsomething just as good at any other burger place. Read more
First time at this Black Tap Burger place. We were warned before being seated that the milkshake machine was down. Kind of odd... since they're known for their supreme shakes. DRINKS: We were going to split a milkshake but couldn't so we each got chargedlemonades, which means they had vodka. They were tasty and easy to drink. FOOD: For apps, we got fried mozzarella cheese andcrispy brussel sprouts. Both were so yummy. The sauce for the mozzarella cheese was delish. The mulberry street burger was gooodas were the wings. The sauce on the wings was on the side. After we finished, we were told the milkshake machine was workingagain so we got the cookies and cream supreme milkshake. It was great looking and tasted amazing. SERVER/SERVICE: Our serverAnthony was great. Was helpful about food choice and kept tabs on us , making sure we were okay. VIBE: It's a casual, chillspot. There's a bar area in the front. They have outdoor dining available as well. Read more
Delicious burgers and fries. Crazy shakes. Small, intimate setting that can get loud when busy. Was busy during much of the open... hours. Full bar with great draft selection. Friendly staff. Read more
Having previously visited Black Tap in Dubai I was keen to return and see how the food compared in their hometown and I was not... dissapointed! The menu has a fantastic selection and the burger I tried (Greg Norman) was superb. The crazy shakes honestly haveto be seen to be believed and without doubt have a wow factor as they are taken through the restaurant. Only reason for 4 starsinstead of 5, service was slow. Slightly unfair as the restaurant was very busy....if they had more staff/more attentive staffthey certainly could of upsold at our table. That being said, I would return as the food was so good! Read more
Had a longer wait than advised but the manager — a nice young lady whose name I can’t recall, and the waitress Amber were... fantastic and made up for the delay. Food was also amazing. The receptionists do need some training as they were a bit crude. Read more
Wow! This place is a legend for their shakes and I know why now. Stopped by after work for a quick bite and a shake and boy was... it a great idea. Was there on a weekday around 5:30pm and had no wait at all. We had the brownie shake and the cookies and creamshake. The cookies and cream shake tasted amazing. The liquid was so cookies and cream it was unbelievable. All the toppings andadd ins were amazing too. I couldn’t even finish my whole shake. We also had burgers that were awesome but the shakes totallystole the show. The staff is super friendly and attentive. The hostess was busy and still friendly and seated us right away,same with our waitress, busy but friendly and on top of our needs. Certainly revisiting! Read more