Reviews for Caribbean Starr in New York, NY
WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE?I WILL NEVER eat from this restaurant again after today, the attitude and the lack of professionalism I... experienced from the very RUDE server was it for me. The food at this restaurant is OVERPRICED but when I am work in Harlem Iwould stop by and always get the curry Goat (ask to taste it because the Curry Goat is usually very salty.) Don?t ask anyquestions about the price, serving size and don?t ask for more specialty rice ( Jerk rice, spinach rice, sea food rice) even ifyou are already paying Extra for it, you will get disrespected and be told ?if you can?t afford it, then don?t order it?. Payingfor my food is not a problem, what I can?t afford is to be DISRESPECTED so I WILL NEVER GO BACK TO THIS RESTAURANT OR RECOMMENDIT TO ANYONE. Read more
This place was okay. Like I will go back if Im in the area but its not a must that I have to return. My friend and I went during... the day and even though inside tables were open, we were instructed we could only eat outside. It felt like they just didn?twant people inside but we went outside and enjoyed our food. Food is a bit pricey but its inflation now so Im not stressingbusinesses about their prices. Most of the food is displayed buffet style. Everything was handled efficiently and clean andpackaged to go well. The food was well seasoned and portioned properly. Read more
Disappointing Goat Roti: Worse roti I have had in a long time. Requested roti on the side but got roti skin totally... saturated/wrapped with curried meat/channa which was extremely hot/spicy. Roti I had was dry and tasted like cardboard. Couldn'tconsume~ had to throw out and was not reimbursed. Read more
Excellent Service ????! The Staff was very attentive to us . The food was so very authentic, " I thought I was in Jamaica." The... Curry Chicken and Curry Shrimp far exceeded expectations (yum:) The OXTAILS are on point! HARLEM NYC ya'll spoiled me:) THANKYOU ( be back ????) Read more
My sistah-friend Sidra and I pre-gamed at the bar with a few glasses of Champagne. Then, we had Salmon, Spinach rice, and fried... Shrimp. It was soooo good! And the presentation was everything (as seen in photos). Looking forward to returning soon. Read more
I agree with a lot of others about the service especially for the price. I paid $27.00 for the sweet chili salmon, which was dry... and I only got one side dish when I believe it was supposed to come with two. This was my first time there and I orderedtakeout. There wasn't any guidance as to how the plates are made or their price. Imo Lighthouse sweet chili salmon is way betterand so is the service. Even a lot cheaper if I recall correctly. I can't see myself give the place another visit. Read more
So I decided to give Carribean Star the benefit of the doubt from last times disappointed oxtail meal. And ordered the medium... version instead of the large. The only real difference between the two is a larger rice portion. Don't need to pay $3 extra forjust rice alone. No matter if you're a rice lover or not. Anyways I am much satisfied with this order of oxtails and they havereinstated my trust in their quality of incredibly delicious Jamaican cuisine. As you can witness from the image they wereagain quite generous with their oxtail portions, the coconut rice is to die for and there is quite sufficient gravy to my likingthe cabbage is also very well seasoned and tender to the bite. Not at all rubbery and bland as it was the previous time. All inall I am totally very well pleased and satisfied with my order. It is as always before the last order worth every single penny. Read more
Hair inside my food this is not the first time and I spent over $30. I also had a large meal and they gave me a small container... of cabbage to go with it, which they left out and I had to make a second trip to go get. For $37 it wasn?t worth it. Read more