Reviews for CASA TuLuM NYC in New York, NY
We were so excited to try Casa Tulum tonight when we saw it was open! Absolutely delicious enchiladas, tampiqueña, seafood... empanada and guacamole!! The staff is incredibly attentive with excellent recommendations and made sure we were taken care of!10/10 dining experience! So excited to have casa tulum in the neighborhood Read more
Was on a solo wander thru the South Street Seaport and was looking for a bloody mary. The other restaurants next to Seaport... House didn?t have one so I landed at their bar. The place has a cute vibe and the staff was warm. I only had the one drink, so Ican?t speak to the food. Pretty solid bloody mary - a little on the sour side which was unexpected but good. Read more
Great area for summer dining. The food is incredible! Try the pastas!!!!! The pesto sauce is phenomenal. Wine list is super... accommodating and the staff are very knowledgeable and friendly. Went there the first time a while ago and decided to have mybirthday there. Do yourself a favor and check out this hidden gem! Read more
Place was nice, clean and welcoming. Music was fun. Food was very good. Would return and recommend!
If you get bad seafood here and send back an entire untouched dish, no one will ask. Odd for a restaurant that might want to... stay in business. It?s the bottom of the barrel for neighborhood Italian/ seafood choices. Avoid. Read more
I love a HAPPY HOUR and Seaport House has one of the best for anyone who likes to keep it simple and chill. My sister and I... opted for appetizers and drinks.. From 5pm-7pm you can go crazy on the $1.50 oysters sold by the dozen or the half dozen. TheirBuffalo Cauliflower is some of the best I have ever tasted, spicy with just a bite but not an overwhelming kick. The texture wasjust right as well, not too hard, not too soft. I also tried the Ceasar Salad $8 HH menu that came with anchovies and a side ofSautéed spinach with garlic $5 side order. Margaritas were a little pricy, but definitely worth it! Everything was DELICIOUS.My personal favorite was the cauliflower. AMBIANCE: We sat in the outdoor space which was VERY posh and comfortable. SERVICE:Even outside, the service was excellent and the waitstaff were very attentive without being annoying. RESTROOMS: 2 clean unisexbathrooms. Who can ask for more? 1 star off because we had to ask about the Happy Hour menu. Also, we were charged forsparkling water that we ordered but never received because they didn't have any at the moment. When we pointed this out on themenu it was quickly rectified, so no harm no foul. Read more
the seafood is very good, very fresh, also quite expensive. the staff were attentive although our waitress wasn't very good at... helping us when we had questions about the bottles of wines. all she said after asking the bartender, who also gave not triedit, is that one is drier than the other but she doesn't remember which is which. luckily, another staff who was slightly moreknowledgeable and actually had an open bottle that he offered us a tasting before we made up our minds which was very nice andhelpful. love the qr codes but the menu font is no good because it's too narrow making it harder to distinguish in low lightingfor many people. Read more
Staff were super friendly here but food was average. Portions were small for both cocktails and entree.