Reviews for Connolly's in New York, NY
The warmth and good spirits of an Irish pub. First we came for breakfast, Full Irish breakfast and Irish Eggs Benedict. Both... were amazingly delicious and hearty. Later we returned to the rooftop area for some satisfying Irish coffees and Guinness. Read more
This place is wonderful! We arrived with a party of 14 for lunch. We had no reservations as we had just arrived from Iowa and... were walking around Times Square. The hostess didn’t even blink. She opened up the upstairs dining room, got us seated, andfound a waitress who was equally amazing! The food was simply delicious. We ordered the calamari and several other appetizersand each was very good. The service was above and beyond. The chicken pot pie was a huge hit, as well as the fish and chips, andsalmon with a walnut crust. The portions are very generous. There was not one dish served to us that wasn’t at least fivestars. If we lived here I would frequent this gem all the time! Read more
Tasty food and drinks from all cuisine, not just Irish, as you may assume from the name. They also have a cute rooftop area but... it only has a limited street view. We ended up eating here twice during our stay nearby because it was a fun place with goodfood Read more
We came to Connolly's because it was right next door to our hotel, and I'm so glad we did! It is the epitome of an authentic... Irish pub. The decor is warm and wood-paneled, and many of the servers even have Irish accents. The staff was all very friendlyand welcoming as well! My husband got the American burger, and I got the fish & chips. The batter on the fish was perfectlycrispy, yet the fish was tender and flakey. My husband ordered his burger rare, and it came out excellently rare (which isactually pretty unusual - he always orders rare and it's usually over cooked). Would definitely recommend Connolly's! Read more
Connolly's is open late which made it the perfect place to eat after a Broadway show. We were seated on the first floor near... the bar with no wait around 11pm. The hostess and wait staff were all very friendly and efficient and the food was served veryquickly. We had Shepherds Pie, Fried Mozzarella and Peanut Butter pie for dessert, all were very good. The atmosphere was greatwith Irish accents everywhere. If you like a good Irish pub definitely check out Connolly's. Read more
Great food! Great service! Truly authentic Irish cuisine! I was sad I couldn’t finish my food! Officially my favorite food... in NYC! Conveniently located right outside our hotel at Times Square. Highly recommend this place! Read more
Food and drinks were good. Lost a star for being seated by entryway (constant traffic and cold). Didn’t want to complain... during a busy dinner hour with no reservation. Servers were attentive. Huntsman sandwich and salmon entrée were both worthhaving again. The local brews were pretty good too. The tiramisu was average. Read more
Food was so good! Hot and fresh. The Connolly’s Lager was a great crisp lager. Highly recommend. Service was outstanding and... our server clearly loved his job. He was quick and efficient. Read more