Reviews for Gray Hawk Grill in New York, NY

My spouse and I dined here opening day 2 years ago. We were amazed at how good the experience was. We were even more amazed that... they could pull that off in 2020! It has only gotten better. It is always clear that this restaurant is run by people who enjoyand respect their profession—so the service is impeccable and friendly; so the food is outstanding; so the space is tasteful,clean and cheerful. You can get a top notch steak here (this is very important to me). Their seafood is equally good. The menuis thoughtful, well balanced and changes appropriately. They know their way around a cocktail! Or so my son tells me. Brunch isa really, really good experience. The UES got lucky with this restaurant Read more

First time coming here. The service was friendly, warm and very knlowedgabwle. Really enjoyed the decor and ambiance. I ordered... a steak and asparagus, it was good, but not the best. The steak was cooked perfectly, but the flavoring was overwhelmed with acharred smokey flavor. Some people may love this, but it's not for me. For the price, I'd prefer a steak from Smith & Wollenskyor Wolfgangs (in the area). That said, I tried the oysters, cod and tuna from other members of my party; all were delicious. Sowould I come back? Absolutely, I saw every other table ordering the burger. Would like to try it, along with the chicken. Read more

Very average (at best) food with very unreasonable prices. Could have bought the salmon from Morton Williams and grilled it... better than they did, for a fraction of the price. $30 for a “truffle” burger that had zero hints of truffle. Don’t reallyunderstand the high ratings for this place, but maybe that’s just me. Read more

Did the boozy brunch option. Drinks were great, food was very tasty, and the servers were very nice. Will definitely be back.

The experience at Gray Hawk Grill was one of a kind. We had two different types of steaks, frites and strip, both grilled to... perfection. The waitress, Bri, was very attentive to details and provided insight to menu options and even gave recommendationsof outside menu specials. An overrall great dining experience. Read more

We loved Gray Hawk Grill because of the foods the service and the atmosphere. The tuna tartare was excellent. We didnt lik the... buffalo cauliflower and the kind waiter immediately replaced it with an excellent homemade burta. The meats - hamburger and NewYork Strip steak were very good and for dessert the coconut cake was delicious. The dishes are large and the value for money isgood. Read more

Such a great experience and would definitely go back! The tuna steak was so delicious and paired perfectly with the bussels... sprouts, tomatoes & capers. I also ordered the Strawberry Fields cocktail (sorry I only had a screenshot from a video if it andI already ate the strawberry haha) but that was so perfect and light, great with any meal or on it’s own! The service wasexcellent as well! My server, Brianne was so kind and helpful when I asked what she recommended. Read more

Starters - Shrimp Cocktail: Tough and tasteless - Kumamoto Oysters: Disappointing leaving absolutely no brine and some pieces... of shell - Burrata: Good, pesto on the side was a nice touch and added a bit of flavor but the burrata itself wasdelicious Mains - Tuna Steak: Delicious and the charred Brussel sprouts were paired really well with the capers Filet: Verygood and the butter topping was a nice added bonus Side - Mashed Potatoes: Were these instant? Service - Excellent Iwould've given more stars with the service and mains being fantastic but the starters left much more to be desired. And thepotatoes... Would I go back? Probably. Everyone was very nice and the mains were enough to make me consider a return. Read more