Reviews for Il Pesce in New York, NY
Great food and Service! we absolutely loved the food, very fresh and tasty. First time trying Octopus and truffle pasta. Best... Cesare salad I have ever had! Service was great. Phillip was very knowledgeable and made sure that we were taken care of. thankyou for the awesome food Read more
Slight above average quality, and ok overall, but not particularly well executed and not particularly warranted by price ($33),... walk in no reservation (6/29/22). Read more
The food is pretty good but their instructions are really confusing. Their signs say to seat yourself but they really mean to... get online and wait for someone to seat you. We sat down, as the sign in the picture says but then they made us get up and geton line just so they could put us in the same seats as before ... but I did like my squid ink chitarra though and the winerecommendation by the waiter was great. So if you're going to come here, make sure you don't seat yourself... Read more
I was at Il Pesce yesterday. I liked thar they had tables available, we’re in a hurry. I had the Tagliata di Manzo, which was... a mall cut of stake. It was good to be honest but the size was dissapointing, for a 6 food guy it was like an entree. In myopinion it was too expensive. Laurita the waiter treat us very nice though. Read more
Was very excited to try Il Pesce inside Eataly market today but was fairly disappointed. Calamari was very fresh, texture was... great but overall tasted very bland and the batter used was not good quality considering how high quality the calamari itselfwas. I also got a stomach ache immediately after eating it (and no I don't have food allergies). The wine was good, service wasalright. But overall I expected a lot better quality. They do have a very diverse seafood menu and I'm sure other items on theirmenu are much better but not sure I'll be returning. ***Update: got extremely sick last night and feel like this definitelycontributed given my immediate stomach ache after eating them. Beware*** Read more
Not sure what waiter the other reviewers had but my boyfriend and I got pretty polite/efficient service sitting at the bar.... Taste was nice but not mind-blowing for the price. Crudo was shockingly small portioned, but we enjoyed the middle one (I thinkit was swordfish with fried capers). Burrata was yum (would recommend), broccoli rabe was fine (nothing special). Can't rememberwhich fish we got for the main but it was well cooked. Read more
Seating is first come first serve which is somewhat inconvenient. But once seated the waitress was very attentive. Food/value... is great. We had beets and salad (at $6 each), plus, trenette (basil pesto) and spicy pasta (don’t remember the name butit’s from the south category). Will definitely go back! Read more
Pasta vongole main course was inferior. Almost no clams. Almost inedible pasta. Unbelievably salty. Like someone spilled salt... in the dish! Terrible service. Rude, inattentive, bad attitude. Read more