Reviews for Libretto's Pizza in New York, NY
Thin crush entirely too soggy like dough.. Did not cook the pizza long enough. Or this wasn't a fresh pie. Not enough cheese... and the sauce is extremely thin. extremely too many black olives. So many you can smell Olive oil all over the pizza. it was awaste of $45.. Definitely will not order from this place again . Totally missing doughboys. I missed the doughboys pizza????.. This customer service that took this order, over the phone. was extremely rude. saying it's a Saturday and he's busy.. Sobusy that he's selling $50 pizza pies that tastes like garbage. like garbage .. I will never spend my money again... peoplethink that they could treat you like anything and take your money. Well posted ???? ???? ???? Read more
Dropped by for a fresh pepronni slice. The guys are friendly and happy to serve you. I'd go for whichever looks the freshest. I... also tried the tiramisu; really great! Read more
Medium thin crispy chewy crust with good flavor. Good coverage of cheese and sauce. (Properly) well cooked cheese, tasty,... flavorful sauce. Doesn't taste like Italian seasoning, but the flavor is very, very good. $3.45 is more than I like to spend forpizza, but I'll still give it a rating of 95. Read more
Best vodka slice in the entire city hands down. An absolute hidden gem. Their cheese slice is very standard and reliable as... well. Overall great traditional Italian pizzeria Read more
Brilliant pizza (thin crust but soft and chewy base) with low prices ($3 for plain, $4 for regular and $5 for special slices) in... a pizza restaurant setting. Strongly recommend. They also have make your own pizza, wine, beer and sodas, dessert ($8 though),ample seating and a nice ambience. I loved both the plain and pepperoni slices I got. It tasted really good and you could eatlike a typical New Yorker by folding it without cracking. Read more
Ordered a pizza from uber eats. I don't know if the pizza was damaged in transit or piorly packaged but either way it was... inedible and next time I'll collect. It looked like it was carried upside down :-( The restaurant replied and apologised, sonot their fault - but if you want to order from here then collect!! Read more
At $3.45 for a cheese slice, it's quite pricey, even for this neighborhood and nyc in general ( $3 at Garlic and $2.75 at most... others). That said though, it's a quality classic NYC style cheese slice and definitely distinguishable from the $1-2 pizzaslices around the city that use cheaper sauces and cheeses. The dough is perfect in its pillowy yet crispy balance - if you'reinto pizza crusts, you know what I mean. The tomato sauce is more on the salty side, can barely taste the tinge of sweetness, sotake note if you prefer sweeter sauces. Good amount of cheese on the slice. Would come back if I were hungry and didn't want towalk any further. I have to say though, compared to Garlic pizza on 2nd Ave or Lunettas on 20th street, this sauce lackscomplexity of flavor. This all based on the classic cheese slice- not comparing the topping slices because that's definitelymore variables and subject to all sorts of preferences and combinations. Read more
Our go to pizzeria in our neighbourhood. Has a wide selection of pizzas, either by the slice or entire pie. All the ones we've... had have been good. Slices are humongous and usually only need one to fill you up. Staff is friendly and efficient. Has indoorseating. Super quick to get a slice if you need something to eat fast. Read more