Reviews for Mi Casita in New York, NY
I got the steak that comes with corn tortillas, yellow rice and black beans. It was okay, but my cup of tea.
Terrible. The food wasn’t up to standards. The chicken on my tacos tasted raw, wasn’t fully cooked. And my torta was missing... ingredients like jalapeños. The bread wasn’t toasted at all. Read more
I wish I could leave a review for the food but we never tasted it. Ordered from here last night via caviar. The app confirmed... the restaurant received the order and it was being made. 45 minutes roll by and no food. We call them and they say it’s 10minutes away. 20 minutes more and no food. We call them again and they say it’s 5 minutes away. Oh, you thought it was over?No. The saga continues. We are now 2 hours out from when we ordered and no food. We call again and they ask us to repeat theentire order. Then we asked what is going on and they hung up on us. Finally, we got our $66 back through the app. I wish Icould comment on the quality of food but I can say the quality of service is an absolute dumpster fire. I have no idea how thisrestaurant has managed to stay open. Let alone in a pandemic. Read more
I got the el pastor 10 inch burrito with chips and guacamole, absolutely great. The el pastor was sweet and salty with a great... amount of beans, the tomatillo salsa is spicy and mixed with the sour cream or guac never overwhelming. I'm incrediblysatisfied. Important to keep in mind that it was still this good after I walked home 15 minutes in the rain. Read more
I am really upset, they took almost 2 hours to deliver the food and on top of that the lady who picked up the phone was Really... rude when being asked about the time. She hung up the phone 2 times and my food arrived almost 2 hours later COLD !!!!!! Thetortilla was cold , I asked for chicken enchiladas and I received steak. I will never order food from this restaurant. I don’trecommend please don’t waste your money .. Read more
Generous portions. Delicious food. What I ordered was definitely mild and not spicy at all. So if you enjoy Mexican but can’t... take the overheating of some Tex-Mex places, this will be your new favorite local spot. They do offer some dishes withjalapeños (which I am very allergic to, so I didn’t try) if you are looking for more bite to your burrito. Read more
12$ 8/10 Tinga Tostadas(3); Ingredients were freshly cut and and portion was enough to fill me up. A bit disappointing that the... tostadas seem to be the Guerrero ones from the supermarket or those that you buy for 2$ where as other authentic mexicanrestaurants have them home made I had a good time here! I stayed for a while due to La Rosa de Guadalupe playing lol and thegood environment ????Back to FOOD, I also had a carnitas Taco???? Being mexican, I'd say the tortilla was little undercookedto the point of breaking by the last bite, 30 seconds would of made it just the way I like it. If youre not Mexican you probablywont mind??????? But! Ingredients were VERY fresh Being that I didnt ask for crispy tortilla, I wont hurt the Tacos gradingbut I'll give it a 10/10 Server was friendly and fast! Read more
Place is like a mom and pop shop for Mexican food. taste like so as well. everything is always fresh and tastes authentic. Great... lemonade great taco's. just order ahead of time, it may take a bit longer because its one or two people on staff cooking butworth the wait and i dont mind supporting this small business. Read more