Reviews for Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana in New York, NY
One of the best Italian restaurants I have had in New York. At least three tables around us with actual Italian people dining... … some of the servers seem to be Italian too. I’d recommend sharing all dishes… the pastas are very well served. We lovedthe truffle bruschetta, the stuffed artichoke salad is so good and the green pasta is amazing too… There are only a fewrestaurants we like coming back, this seems to be one of them. Read more
The texture and taste of the octopus feet are very satisfying. I'm not sure if the bottom layer is mashed potatoes or egg... yolks. The taste feels very good. The lobster pasta and pasta bolognese are also good. But I thought the pasta bolognese was abit salty. Service was attentive. Dining here is a good choice. Read more
My partner and I came here on a Saturday evening sans reservation. Be warned, this is a very popular place so you’ll have to... wait. However, the wait is definitely worthwhile. The staff is very friendly, and once you are at the table food and drinksflow pretty quickly. We started with the stuffed calamari. Then we had the sardine fennel and orange salad, a hit with mypartner. It had a beautiful balance between the saltiness of the sardines and the sweetness of the oranges, I definitelyrecommend over the calamari. For our pasta, we ordered the tagliatelle with ragu and the eggplant. They were both excellent butif you have to pick—go with the tagliatelle. It was delicious and a perfect portion to share with someone else. Overall,definitely worthwhile. Read more
We are Italian food fans, and we enjoy traveling the world trying some good Italian restaurants. We found Piccola Cucina... randomly and we loved the entire experience. Great food, amazing service, and good vibes. Highly recommend it Read more
Fist of all, inside seating is crowded, little table spacing. Second, mediocre food experience. We had swordfish as appetizer,... hardly taste the original fish flavor as tomato sauce and mozzarella are way too strong; Lobster linguine is mediocre, unlessyou are a person of spaghetti or noodles very much, otherwise you had better choice to enjoy seafood/Italian food. To be honest,not impressed and basically don’t get the hype. Read more
Went there in a really heavy raining day. Surprisingly the restaurant was still packed. Food was great and chief was there. The... service is amazing, the staff wanted to redo our pasta when she knew other staff accidentally threw away the left takeouts. Recommend to any one want to some good Italian food and vibe. Remember to book a table… they are really busy. Read more
The BEST Italien restaurant in NYC!! This is a real traditional and original authentic Italian restaurant. Loved the food. Loved... the atmosphere. And super nice service. Definitely will come back. Read more
Four and a half stars We generally enjoyed the food. We’d recommend the Sea Bass and Eggplant Parm appetizer. We give neutral... to slightly negative marks to the side of grilled vegetables and the sardines. The servers vary widely in quality. Read more