Reviews for Rosie's in New York, NY
Stopped by Rosie’s before a night out to grab a bite and a couple of drinks. We were greeted by Brendan the very nice host who... immediately convinced us we should try the place out. The bar tenders were nice too and gave us recommendations on what to try.We sat at the bar and ordered the Passionfruit Margarita, Queso Fundido, Quesadilla and Chicken Taco. The cocktail was amazingand all the food came out quick and tasted amazing. It’s a great atmosphere with low lights and background music, a greatplace for friends to meet up before a night out! Read more
Rosie’s hit the spot! Had a great dinner with friends. Service was super friendly and attentive, food and drinks were... awesome. Loved the atmosphere, beautiful restaurant. Will definitely come back Read more
Came here for dinner and drinks with a group of friends and it really hit the spot. The team were incredibly accomodating,... moving us to a table outdoors when one freed up to allow us to be near our pup. They even brought her out a lil treat! The foodand drinks are well priced for a full service restaurant. Strongly recommend the tasty shrimp, fish and mushroom tacos(pictured). Read more
Tacos were decent. I do think there are better places to get tacos around the area for the same price or even cheaper. Also the... churros had this weird aftertaste. Wouldn’t recommend getting them even if they look delicious. Read more
A decent Mexican place. The corn tortillas are highlightable, and the flavors are on point. We mostly went with the tacos; the... Al pastor has a flavorful and authentic achiote marinade, but the meat is a little dry. The shrimp taco is decent, but overfried such that the batter took away from the shrimp. The barbacoa was perhaps my favorite - it was tender with some delightfulstewed onions on top. The fish taco had a good beer batter. The mole was recommendable. It leaned sweet and had fruity notes,but had less depth than a storied mole. It came with sweet potato, an interesting sweet pairing that I didn’t mind. The quesofundido was solid, but it was strange that it came as the last dish of the meal even though it was in the appetizers section. Read more
The rating for this spot reflects my feelings but I could see someone else giving it 5 stars if it were their speed. It is a... party spot and you need to know that going into it. I did not know that and was thrown off by how extremely loud and hectic itwas. I also love Mexican food, especially spicy Mexican food. I looked over the menu and couldn’t find anything spicy on itand asked the waiter about that. They explained that their clientele don’t tend to like spicy so they don’t have any disheswith spice. They were super accommodating and brought me a hot sauce with the pork dish I got (which was actually delicious!).So ultimately the strikes were the lack of relaxed ambiance and lack of authenticity, but still good food with kindservice. Also, the servers kept calling my girl friend and me “my love” at the end of every sentence. We felt neutral aboutit but just was an odd observation. Read more
We came early right before the usual dinner time on a Friday. Service was great and the food was absolutely amazing. Our waiter... was very friendly and informative on some of the dish recommendations! Nice touch on chopping up the Elote for convenience. Theinterior is lively as well! Read more
We have been to Rosie’s many times. We were there for dinner on Nov 5, 2022. The service was very good. The food has changed a... little bit. We ordered the Calabaza Frita and it was delicious, the Tlayuda not so much. I had to send it back because it waschewy and cold but the new one was good. We also ordered the Ceviche de Camarones and it tasted like it was prepared way toolong in advance. The drinks tasted like if they were watered down, it wasn’t the same taste of the last 3 times we have eatenthere. The place was crowded and the staff was really busy. We love this place but this last visit wasn’t good. Read more