Reviews for Schmackary's in New York, NY
I got the PB Cup cookie sundae and it was a bit dry. The soft serve wasn?t particularly impressive. I?m sure their other menu... items are good. I got the ice cream sundae and it was alright. Read more
They have the best cookies ever ! I stopped for breakfast and some wifi for a few hours in the morning. The place was so cute... and cozy and the staff very nice. Coffee and cookies are great and wifi works just great. I loved their cookie box too =) Read more
Good cookies! Just go early or they might run out of the one you want. Like today peanut butter cup was out but we did go after... dinner. Was our second time here and both times there was a short line to the door. Read more
I was expecting something great and it turned out to really be lacking in flavor. The pictures look better than they taste. The... cookies were rather tough and tasted more like backing soda / powder and sugar. I do have to say though the frosting on top ofthe cookies is HEAVEN! BUT OVERALL NOT WORTH 3.75 FOR TATSY FROSTING. Save the money and just buy frosted cookies at Target. Read more
Reading the many glowing reviews, I was hopeful. But I was completely let down. I ordered 6 chocolate chip cookies through... Seamless. I took a few bites and had to toss the rest. They were cold, excessively oily, stale, and unbearably salty. Never hadsimple chocolate chip cookies taste this bad. And now my stomach is actually hurting from the cookies. Deeply disappointed. Atleast I tried. Read more
Great cookies and great offerings! We got there before closing and got our cookies for ?but one get one free!? They also had... gluten free and vegan options ? it seemed that they have at least one gluten free and one vegan option each day. These cookieswere everything we needed on a cold night! ???? You can bet we?ll be back for more! Read more
OMFG - serving other worldly cookie realness, the best cookies your find anywhere!!! Such creativity, design, and concepts?... you?re definitely come back. Owned and operated by the best people you?ll ever meet. And the coffee is badass too. Read more
My husband and I came here right before closing so they offered buy one get one free, how generous! He is a raving fan of the... simple but classic chocolate chip and I am more adventurous and decided to try the cookies and cream. The chocolate chip wasn?tbad it just seemed to have too much and I did enjoy my cookies and cream although the frosting on top was a bit too sweet.Overall we did enjoy this shop and will purchase from you again. Read more